Both are crime movies, but the 1986 title, starring Billy Crystal and Gregory Hines, goes for laughs, while the 2006 title, with a cast lead by Paul Walker, goes for tense dramatic action. According to Rotten Tomatoes, older is better.
Warner & Weinstein’s ‘Butler’ Battle: 10 Other Movies With Matching Titles (Photos)
What's the big deal, anyway? Here are 10 other movies that share the same title