'Idol' Recap: Boy, Have I Got a Sob Story for You!

February, 09, 2011 9:39 pm | Comments On #American Idol, Jennifer Lopez, recap, Steven Tyler, Television

After last week’s Los Angeles debacle, Seacrest teased that they just might be saving the best for last when it came to “Idol” auditions. Don’t get too excited. We didn’t find any Carrie Underwoods.

The opening scene of a sobbing contestant should’ve warned us. In a trend that is becoming increasingly annoying, tonight’s trip to San Francisco seemed more about tragedy than talent.

When did “Tell us about yourself” become code for “What’s the most heartbreaking thing that’s ever happened to you?” It is starting to feel like the eligibility requirements have less to do with age or vocal...

Read More

'Idol' Recap: I Was Wondering Where All the William Hungs Have Been Hiding

February, 03, 2011 10:03 pm | Comments On #American Idol, Jennifer Lopez, Randy Jackson, recap, Ryan Seacrest, Steven Tyler, Television

Los Angeles is the entertainment capital of the world, the “City of Dreams.” Well, after Thursday’s “Idol” auditions, a better moniker may be the “City of Delusions,” as the Angeleno Idols have clearly broken with all reality when it comes to their star quality.

I guess we should’ve known when we found out MySpace was involved. That’s right, in a move as cutting edge as the Discman, “Idol” joined forces with the has-been of the social networking family. Some 16,000 hopefuls auditioned via the site and the best were invited to Los Angeles (not to be confused with “Hollywood”) to sing for the judges. 

Don’t they...

Read More

'Idol' Recap: John Wayne, Barbie & Ken ... and Naughty, Naught Steven Tyler

February, 02, 2011 9:33 pm | Comments On #American Idol, Jennifer Lopez, Randy Jackson, Steven Tyler, Television

The Austin auditions opened up with what sure seemed to be an tongue-in-cheek apology for Steven Tyler’s “outrageous behavior” last week. They couldn't have been too sorry, because it was immediately followed by a clip of the adorably incorrigible Tyler offering up words rhyming with contestant Jake Muck’s last name.

Inappropriate commentary from Tyler? Check.

Flawless hair and makeup on Lopez? Also covered.

So what was missing from the Austin round of auditions? Well, for one, there was nary a 15-year-old in sight. The last two weeks of auditions would have us believe that droves of young teens will soon descend on Hollywood, armed with Miley Cyrus sleeping bags and Proactiv Solution (a product coincidentally endorsed by Seacrest “girlfriend” Julianne Hough)....

Read More

Simon Who? How Did 'American Idol' Ever Exist Before Steven Tyler?

January, 27, 2011 10:18 pm | Comments On #American Idol, Jennifer Lopez, Randy Jackson, Ryan Seacrest, Steven Tyler, Television

When “Idol” announced that it was visiting Nashville again for auditions, you had to wonder: Isn’t Music City just a little too professional for America’s favorite amateur hour?  

Stop making your protest signs. While the home of country music definitely provided some talent, auditions weren’t quite on par with the talent “situation” in Jersey, not to mention New Orleans. Although 17,000 hopefuls showed up, it looks like most of the city’s true musicians were too busy waiting tables.

Case in point: Former Miss Teen USA Stormi Henley (not a porn star) auditioned because she really wanted to see how far she could make it on her talent alone.  While she was gorgeous and pageant-pleasant, her voice left much to be desired.  Ironically, it was Miss Image Conscious herself, J. Lo, who gave her a “no....

Read More

Recap: 'Idol' Courts the Biebers -- Plus, Another Steven Tyler Love Child

January, 26, 2011 10:38 pm | Comments On #American Idol, Jennifer Lopez, Randy Jackson, reality TV, Steven Tyler, Television

“This is the unassuming season,” declared Randy during this week’s Milwaukee auditions.  Granted, it’s difficult to be anything but “unassuming” when your town’s claim to fame is cheese.  (And Season 8’s Danny Gokey!)

That being said, Jackson’s statement has validity.  Bullied ginger kids, portly crooners and image-impaired ingenues have helped form one of the running themes of Season 10: “don’t judge a book by its cover.” Tonight’s auditions continued along those lines with a White House intern, a friend-deprived auditor and, of course, a few talented teens.

That’s right. Yet again, the standouts are young. In fact, Seacrest even mentioned that every 15-year-old who auditioned on Day 1 had garnered a Golden Ticket.

Say what?!

Honky-tonk baseball player...

Read More

'American Idol': Steven Tyler's Lippy Love Children Show Up for Night 2

January, 20, 2011 8:14 pm | Comments On #American Idol, Jennifer Lopez, Ryan Seacrest, Steven Tyler, Television

"American Idol's" New Orleans audition show started off almost as sensationally as the season premiere, with a tearful contestant sitting at a piano singing Charlie Chaplin’s “Smile” before breaking into full-fledged sobs and storming off.  Perhaps the “Big Easy” wasn’t going to go that easily after all.

Not to worry, though, the rest of the show Thursday continued on much like the night before. Well, mostly. One glaring change was the lack of lawsuit-worthy remarks from Steven Tyler. In Jersey, we were treated to a full mini-montage of his lascivious comments but Thursday night’s airing showcased things like (scoff!) actual singing.

In their place were insinuations that Tyler could be the unknowing father to any contestant who walked in with those telling trout lips. Tyler insisted that his doppelganger...

Read More

'American Idol': How It Went With the Diva, the Dawg and the Demon of Screamin’

January, 19, 2011 11:33 pm | Comments On #American Idol, Jennifer Lopez, Randy Jackson, Ryan Seacrest, simon cowell, Steven Tyler, Television

The Diva, the Dawg and the Demon of Screamin’.

These are not characters in a Grimms Brothers story. Rather, they are the newest players in the millennial fairytale that is ... “American Idol.”

Last night’s season 10 premiere was perhaps the most anticipated in the show’s history. Yes, it was the debut of the new judging triumvirate, featuring Jennifer Lopez, Steven Tyler and veteran Randy Jackson. Perhaps more importantly, though, it marked the official end to the banal season 9, and that in itself is a bonus.

Also read our recap: Steven Tyler's the New Simon -- But in a...

Read More

10 Predictions for Season 10 of ‘American Idol’

January, 18, 2011 1:53 pm | Comments On #Aerosmith, American Idol, Jennifer Lopez, music, Nigel Lythgoe, simon cowell, Steven Tyler, Television

“American Idol” is back!

Wednesday, after a lackluster last season, the reality show ratings behemoth returns for a 10th season to create another singing sensation … or, if recent winners like Lee DeWyze are any indication, not. 

Host Ryan Seacrest and judge Randy Jackson are still there, but there’s been a lot of changes. There was the departure of Simon Cowell and the return of Executive Producer Nigel Lythgoe from “So You Think You Can Dance." Then there was the introduction of online auditions and the painfully teased announcement of new judges of Jennifer Lopez and Aerosmith’s Steven Tyler.

Now change can be good but to reclaim its former...

Read More

Wait, Was Simon Cowell a Contestant?

May, 27, 2010 6:40 am | Comments On #American Idol, Lee DeWyze, paula abdul, simon cowell, Television

ALSO READ: "12 Worst Moments in 'Idol's' Worst Season."

“Tonight is about Crystal and Lee.”

How did Ryan Seacrest actually manage to say that with a straight face? The theme of Season 9 (other than “jumping the shark”) has been “moments.”  Well, last night’s “moments” didn’t feature our two finalists at all. With multiple montages of Simon fondling his nipples and crushing the dreams of auditioners (not to mention an awkward stand-up routine from prodigal daughter Paula Abdul), it seemed that last night was really about giving Simon Cowell a big send-off.

...

Read More

Crystal's the Best Singer, But Not the Real 'Idol'

May, 26, 2010 6:16 am | Comments On #American Idol, Crystal Bowersox, Lee DeWyze, Ryan Seacrest, simon cowell, Television

Tuesday night’s final performance show left me a little fearful to make a prediction as to who your next American Idol will be, America.

You see, it depends on what your definition of an American Idol actually is. Is it about singing or is it about being commercial? Is it about developing as an artist or is it about already coming into the season as an artist? (And scoring an “Artist” T-shirt from Jamie Foxx!)

From the very beginning, Crystal Bowersox has been deemed “the one to beat.” Only recently did the judges, in an apparent attempt to make the competition seem like, well, an actual competition, start to pimp out Lee DeWyze to the voting public. Well, call me the stereotypical gullible...

Read More