‘Enlisted’ Showrunner on Criticism of Military Portrayal: ‘It's Horsesh-t’

'Enlisted' Showrunner on Criticism of Military Portrayal: 'It's Horsesh-t'

Kevin Biegel hopes people will give his show a chance

New Fox series “Enlisted” is facing some of the same questions about the appropriateness of its humor as another new Fox comedy, “Dads.”

“Enlisted” is a silly portrayal of three brothers in the military posted at a Florida-based Army Rear Detachment unit. Their platoon is filled with ne'er-do-wells and soldiers unfit for combat, whose stateside days are filled with menial tasks as their more competent peers are deployed for war.

Also read: TCA: ‘Enlisted’ Producer Explains What's Funny About War

Show creator Kevin Biegel (“Cougar Town,” “Scrubs”) described Rear D this way to TheWrap: “They are the guys who take care of the base. Sometimes their job is ridiculous, sometimes it’s the heaviest thing in the world. Some days you're mowing lawns, some day you're telling someone their loved one has died.”

It's a real assignment in the armed forces, and — at least early in the season — it is depicted as an unglamorous and somewhat shameful designation, in a unit comprised of men and women who could never have possibly made it through boot camp.

Some people, military veterans and civilians alike, have expressed disapproval to Biegel and his cast about portraying the military in that light. He understands, but thinks the complaint is unfair.

“I think there's a certain segment of people who automatically see a TV show about the military and say, ‘You can't do that,'” he told TheWrap. He added, “It's horseshit. You can tell a story about anything.”

Geoff Stults, who plays lead character Sgt. Pete Hill, told TheWrap that he isn't shocked about some of the backlash: ”It's inevitable, people don't like to be made fun of,” Hill said. “There's a reason that the U.S. Army hasn't officially endorsed the show — they don't want to look silly.”

Also read: Military Channel Changes Name to American Heroes Channel

“Dads” was criticized for different reasons. It has fielded criticism from an Asian-American group over stereotypical jokes in its opener.

Kevin-BiegelLike the “Dads” team, Biegel (left) swore that if viewers give his show a chance, they will find depth to balance out the surface gags: ”We're not doing the typical goofball approach to this,” Biegel insisted.

The failed soldiers may even head to a war zone, Biegel said. If so, the staff would handle with care. ”We'd have to do our homework and make sure we really get it right,” Biegel said. “We'd never do anything if we feel it was disrespecting or making fun of or mocking.”

Also read: Fox Orders Hart Hanson Crime Drama ‘Backstrom’ Starring Rainn Wilson

War or no war, Biegel's show will set aside the silly approach for serious topics at times. One plotline includes Hill dealing with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder.

“There are a few episodes where it’s a little heavier than the other ones,” Biegel said. “I want to gain the audience's trust before we go to these heavier place.”

As a showrunner, Biegel sees one big advantage to the military setting: “It's a very natural way to have people come in and leave show.”

And Biegel does not lack for confidence in his work, or his work ethic, saying of “Enlisted,” “It's got to be the most ambitious show on television. There are huge things that come up during the rest of the season.”

“Enlisted” premieres Friday at 9:30 p.m. on Fox.

  • http://www.warrenjasonstreet.com/ WJS

    I don't think anyone is upset that the Army is being mocked; the premise of the show is just too much to take. The Army would never station three brothers in the same unit with the same chain of command. If you can't get one of the basic details right, it's hard to suspend disbelief and enjoy the show.

    Mocking the Army is part of American history; it is not a sacred cow. But when you get things wrong, the satirical aspect falls flat.

    • Buck Rogers

      Most people seem to forget that its almost impossible to portray the military as more absurd than it actually is. People that have served know perfectly well that the reality is often far more absurd than fiction portrays it.

      Having siblings on the same base would be plausible, but having three brothers in a unit is just plain lazy writing. Might as well have their CO be their father while they're at it.

      • ColoMom

        See a reply to you above.

  • SandyLester

    puke

  • ColoMom

    Being married to a now retired AF vet & having worked for the Army ( as a RN ) I decided to watch ‘Enlisted’ I turned to another program after about 10 minutes. It was a load of ‘crap'. The Sgts. I knew would have put up with this behavior for about the same 10 minutes I watched Enlisted. If anything I sometimes they thought they were a bit too rigid. But then again the reason for the military is to protect the country & prepare for what we don't want- War. So you don't want these “F” ups working along side of you.
    And to ‘Buck Rogers’ really, really ??? Why do I get the feeling that you didn't even make it thru basic training.. Or are you a wannabee Pilot or Naval ship commander??? Hmmm “fess up’ its good for you.

  • oyez

    So we can suspend belief for shows like NYPD Blue, NCIS, and ER, but not Enlisted? This show honors relationships and difficult situations, and it honors the military and those who serve. Moreover, when they get it wrong they reach out to the community and fix it. Seems to me like they've got some integrity. Why so harsh?

    And ColoMom, mocking people doesn't suit you or your nursing profession.