Top 9 of 2009: The Year in TV

Top 9 of 2009: The Year in TV

Published: December 31, 2009 @ 4:47 pm
Print this page
By Josef Adalian

1. The performance of "Don't Stop Believing" at the end of the "Glee" pilot. Sure, it was a moving plot point -- one of the year's highlights -- but the Journey anthem also summed up exactly why this show's success was such an important milestone in 2009 TV.

Most industry insiders, including some inside Fox, were pretty convinced that right around now, Internet-based fan groups and TV critics would be teaming up in a last-ditch attempt to save Ryan Murphy's crazysexyfunnycool musical dramedy. After all, the show doesn't fit into any one category, it had no stars and, at first blush, it seemed to be all about ... losers. 

But a funny thing happened on the way to Save Our Shows-ville. Thanks in part to one of the decade's best TV marketing launch campaigns, "Glee" has been a solid Nielsen player since its premiere -- and is nothing less than a smash hit when other metrics are applied, such as album sales and online buzz.

In an age when a 3 demo rating is now considered success, "Glee" proves that a show doesn't have to be a straight-down-the-middle play in order to work. And that's something worth singing about.

2. The Michael Jackson Memorial. It could've been a train wreck, a maudlin display of celebrity egos. Instead, producer Ken Ehrlich, as he's done so many times in his career, managed to organize an event that was understated and moving. The highlight, of course, couldn't be scripted: When Paris Jackson spoke about her father, it was hard not to get choked up. Suddenly, the Icon, the Artist, the King of Pop was simply ... Dad. 

3. Any given night on cable. While broadcasters had one of their best years in memory in terms of new hits, cable in 2009 controlled most of TV's pop-culture buzz. Hardly a week went by without one network or another touting record ratings, while critics and TV journalists couldn't stop kvelling over the quality of the scripted shows cable churned out.
Cable, of course, has been cranking out good shows for at least a decade.  
But 2009 represented something of a tipping point, as more and more networks continued to find some measure of success with original fare -- from AMC's "Mad Men" and "Breaking Bad" to micro-niche players such as Starz's "Party Down" and SoapNet's "Being Erica." Throw in the fact that pay cable has never been hotter, while basic cable networks such as FX and TNT have never been more prolific, and suddenly, even a great year for the Big 4 seems kinda week compared to the cable hit machine.
Bottom line: If you ran a cable network and didn't have a big hit in 2009, you really should find a new job.
4. The comedy comeback. ABC's gutsy decision to schedule four brand new half-hour sitcoms on Wednesday nights this fall seemed foolhardy -- until it actually worked. Three of the quartet -- "Modern Family," "Cougar Town" and "The Middle" -- all got picked up for full seasons, were greeted with good-to-excellent reviews and seem very likely to be back next fall (assuming "American Idol" doesn't crush them next month).
Tags: Television, web television
Sign Up For First Take

Get Our Daily Email, and Receive Invitations to Our Screenings Series

Start your day with all of the news worth knowing

What's First Take?

Description

The Box tries to make sense of all things television. 

Subscribe to The Box
Most Popular
Columns
Wrap Tweets