Don Lemon Accuser Ordered to Pay $77,000 in Attorney Fees

Recent developments cast doubt on a lawsuit’s assault and battery claims

Getty Images

In an 18-page long ruling, a federal judge ruled Wednesday that Dustin Hice, who has accused CNN host Don Lemon of assault and battery, must pay Lemon $77,000 in attorney fees.

U.S. Magistrate Judge Thomas Locke’s based his ruling on Hice’s violation of court rules. More documents recently filed have further brought the plaintiff’s credibility into question, and two witnesses originally for Hice have switched sides and now deny Hice’s accusations. 

Hice’s claim involves a July 2018 night at Murf’s Backstreet Tavern in Sag Harbor on Long Island, New York. Hice attempted to buy Don Lemon a lemon drop drink, but the CNN anchor refused, according to Hice’s lawsuit. Following the refusal, Hice claims Lemon came up to him, rubbed his genitals and put his fingers on Hice’s mustache while asking, “Do you like pussy or dick?”  

Lemon has since categorically denied the allegations.

Hice’s lawsuit further claims that Hice “fled” the bar and developed mental health problems from the incident. Hice also claims as a result that he couldn’t socialize or work his summer bartending job in the Hamptons town. 

Neither CNN nor Hice’s attorneys immediately responded to TheWrap’s requests for comment.

According to Advocate, one of Hice’s former witnesses, Isabel Peters, has countered Hice’s claims of withdrawal and trauma and said she never witnessed the event take place. Peters’ account of the night was submitted in a sworn deposition.

Peters, Hice and his friend George Gounelas did go to Murf’s on July 15, 2018, and Hice did see Don Lemon. Peters claims she didn’t see any incident like the one Hice described, and she also claims that Hice’s behavior did not noticeably change after the incident at all. 

Gounelas has also since recanted his testimony that he witnessed the incident.