Oscar Ratings Collapse: What a 16-Percent Drop Means for the Live Telecast
ABC has little to lose while the Oscars organization may be setting itself up for a rough future
Jethro Nededog | February 23, 2015 @ 7:06 PM
Last Updated: February 24, 2015 @ 9:36 AM
Racial controversy, a tight match between “Birdman” and “Boyhood” and a new host in Neil Patrick Harris just weren’t enough to give ABC’s Oscars telecast a winning ratings boost over last year.
In fact, the audience dropped significantly. Pulling in 36.6 million total viewers on Sunday night — 6.4 million fewer than 2014’s 10-year high, according to overnight numbers – the audience represents a six-year low in total viewers for the awards show and a 16 percent drop in viewership.
By comparison, two of the other biggest live televised events this year saw increases in viewership. January’s Golden Globes telecast snagged 20.9 million viewers – a 10-year high for the show. The Globes were hosted by Amy Poehler and Tina Fey and gave “Boyhood” and “The Grand Budapest Hotel” the top movie prizes.
Meanwhile, the Super Bowl drew a stunning 114.4 million viewers earlier this month on NBC – making it the most-watched broadcast in TV history.
Those shows prove that live viewing isn’t necessarily falling every year and people will show up for the right combination of participants, performers or nominees.
So what happened at the Oscars? There are a few probable reasons the show would see such a drop:
1. Nominees lack box office might.
The biggest culprit appears to be the movies, for the most part an eclectic mix of mainly quirky and thoughtful indie films that did fair-to-middling business at the box office. However artful, they didn’t generate much mainstream interest at multiplexes or for Sunday night’s show. One can’t help but wonder how the show would have done with “Gone Girl,” “Interstellar” and “The LEGO Movie” in the mix.
2. No big watershed moments.
A big moment can bring in new viewers and hold on to them as the show goes on — especially now with the speed that social media can make a moment viral. Sunday’s show had nothing close to last year’s star-studded selfie with Ellen DeGeneres.
3. The longer the show, the less people are watching.
A long show can be a ratings killer. People begin falling like flies as the show reaches its third hour. So, going over can be deadly to the its numbers. This year’s show ran 48 minutes over its allotted time — eight minutes longer than last year’s telecast.
The decline doesn’t worry ABC, however, which has the upper hand in the broadcasting deal, TheWrap has learned. Regardless of incremental ratings falls, the network wouldn’t be able to program anything that could come near to the amount of live eyeballs that the Oscars telecast attracts.
Even when the show runs over its three hours of allotted time, it doesn’t bother the network — even though it has plenty viewers complaining on social media — for the very same reason as above: It’s a huge amount of viewers.
And when the show doesn’t perform to the same level of ratings as the previous year, still the network doesn’t bat an eyelid. As apparently, ABC doesn’t guarantee advertisers that the show will match previous numbers.
That’s very different to when a series misses its goals and then must provide advertisers with what’s called “make-goods,” meaning networks give advertisers more time on other programs or on digital platforms to make up for the impressions purchased by advertisers that weren’t delivered.
So, why do advertisers put up with it? Again, there are very few TV events that get the amount of live viewership that the Oscars receive.
Another reason advertisers don’t mind a fall in the Oscars ratings is its attractive demo: an upscale, female audience with money to spend.
So, if both the network and the advertisers are OK with falling ratings, who’s getting the short end of the stick?
The Academy may find that it could pay for losing viewers in the long run. Its current contract with ABC runs through 2020. If it continues to lose viewers, that will take away some of its negotiating power when it’s time to renew.
Then, again, the Academy can offer up its viewership to the other networks if ABC attempts to use the ratings falls against the group.
Still, no one really wants to walk away from viewers. But, even if a contingent of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences wanted to make changes — like handing out technical awards off-screen in order to shorten the show’s length — the structure of the Academy makes that nearly impossible.
AMPAS decisions are made by a board of governors made up of three representatives from each of the 17 Academy branches, which means the below-the-line branches outnumber the actors, directors and writers by a substantial number. Those branches have always closed ranks to resist any attempt to move categories off the air, no matter how much ABC and viewers might wish for a more streamlined show. Those branches also now occupy most if not all of the officer positions, so they’ve got the power.
In fact, viewers (and the ratings they do or don’t deliver) seem to have very little power over anything that has to do with movie’s biggest night.
Steve Pond, Tony Maglio and Todd Cunningham contributed to this report.
Julianne Moore stuns in both a red frock and with her performance in "Still Alice." She claimed the Desert Palm Achievement Award for her turn as a woman suffering early onset Alzheimer's. “Obviously it was a very emotional role, but I brought home the joyful parts, the appreciation of life and of my own family," Said Moore. "This was a story about facing loss, but also about acknowledging those things.”
Jeff Vespa
"Birdman," star Michael Keaton and director Alejandro González Iñárritu, strike a distinguished pose. “Thirty minutes ago, my personal Birdman inside was telling me, ‘You are a piece of shit!’ And I believed him. But five minutes later he said, ‘You are the best!’” said Iñárritu
Jeff Vespa
Keaton presented Iñárritu with director of the year saying, “We work in a business that instills narcissism, self-involvement and ego ... so I can’t tell you how great it feels not to talk about myself tonight.”
Jeff Vespa
Rosamund Pike claimed the Breakthrough Award for her wicked turn in "Gone Girl," though in an acceptance speech admitted, "not a week went by when I didn’t come home from the set thinking, 'I can’t do this.'”
Jeff Vespa
Rosamund Pike once told her agent that she wanted to work with Fincher, only to be told that Fincher would never cast a Bond girl. Never say never. “I got to play every part of being a woman: the sexy and fun-loving side, the nurturing and kind side, even if it was an act, the angry side, the vulnerable side, the truly diabolical side. It was everything, and it was thrilling," she said.
— Rosamund Pike, Gone Girl
Jeff Vespa
Best supporting actor nominee for "Whiplash, J.K. Simmons said: “I like being the supporting guy. And that was obviously part of the joy of doing 'Whiplash,' because this is just a bigger supporting part than usual. But I have no illusions about being a movie star. I’m just glad to be able to work.”
Jeff Vespa
Golden boy Benedict Cumberbatch is a darling of Hollywood and the Internet, but missed a certain "Imitation Game" costar. "Keira Knightley thought this was taking place in Palm Beach,” he said, “so she couldn’t be here.”
Jeff Vespa
“Alan Turing wasn’t just a lone, troubled genius who was awkward and difficult and different," Benedict Cumberbatch (with Morten Tyldum) said about his "The Imitation Game" character. "He perhaps became like that over time, but I think that was very much from losing his first love, being a homosexual man at a time of intolerance, working in a very secret environment. the script showed us that complex, very empathizable and human man.”
Jeff Vespa
Benedict Cumberbatch, with director Morten Tyldum, said of the "Imitation Game" cryptologist: "Alan Turing was a war hero, he was a gay icon, and he was the father of modern computer science.”
Jeff Vespa
"The Imitation Game's" behind-the-scenes foursome: Editor William Goldenberg, producer Nora Grossman, writer Graham Moore and producer Ido Ostrowsku.
Jeff Vespa
Ido Ostrowsky and Nora Grossman of "The Imitation Game" cracked the code for desert magic, as their cast claimed Best Ensemble.
Jeff Vespa
Math never looked so good: "The Imitaiton Game's" supporting actors Matthew Beard, Alex Lawther and Allen Leech.
Jeff Vespa
Best Supporting Actor Oscar nominee Robert Duvall accepted the PSFF Icon Award. “When I was growing up, the only thing I knew about drama was cowboys and Indians. I said, ‘I want to be an Indian.’ I was shocked when I found out that you have to be born an Indian," said "The Judge" actor. "So I said, ‘OK, I’ll be a cowboy.’”
Jeff Vespa
"Wild" women Laura Dern and Reese Witherspoon, who said of the actress who played her mother: "She can turn any press junket or film festival into the best party you’ve ever been to."
Jeff Vespa
“We walked, we shared the stories of our lives, and we put the film together for everyone who has ever felt lost in their life," Reese Witherspoon said about working with "Wild" co-star Laura Dern
Jeff Vespa
"Selma" actor David Oyelowo said: “It’s an amazing thing when a role in a film comes along that you know is going to be one of the greatest things you will ever do in your life.”
Jeff Vespa
A PSFF highlight came when Brad Pitt introduced David Oyelowo and taught the whole crowd how to pronounce his name.
Jeff Vespa
Eddie Redmayne's remarkable turn in "The Theory of Everything" captivated the PSFF jury to the point of awarding him the Desert Palm Achievement Award.
Jeff Vespa
Felicity Jones brought a red lip and a bright smile to support her "Theory of Everything" costar Eddie Redmayne.
Jeff Vespa
“Day one, I’ll never forget, we were shooting in Cambridge. It was my first scene playing young Stephen, and Jane came running up and said, ‘No, Ed, his hair would be much messier!’ What an extraordinary thing to have Jane Hawking doing my hair," Eddie Redmayne (with Felicity Jones and James Marsh) recalled of filming "The Theory of Everything."
Jeff Vespa
“There’s something so universal about the human condition of growing up with siblings and parents, with how we maneuver through the world over time -- you can’t not relate to it on some level, which means the response to this film has been fun and heartfelt and kind of beautiful," Richard Linklater said of "Boyhood's" 12 year journey.
Jeff Vespa
1 of 21
Before the Oscars are handed out, see where the road to gold began for Eddie Redmayne, Julianne Moore and Alejandro González Iñárritu with photos by Jeff Vespa at the Palm Springs Film Festival
Julianne Moore stuns in both a red frock and with her performance in "Still Alice." She claimed the Desert Palm Achievement Award for her turn as a woman suffering early onset Alzheimer's. “Obviously it was a very emotional role, but I brought home the joyful parts, the appreciation of life and of my own family," Said Moore. "This was a story about facing loss, but also about acknowledging those things.”