Shocking ‘Bachelor’ Selection Brings Out the Confused, Disappointed Twitter Memes: ‘Who?’

But hey, we found one former contestant who wants to watch Arie

Tony Maglio | September 7, 2017 @ 6:24 AM Last Updated: September 7, 2017 @ 7:06 AM

Bachelor Season 20

ABC

ABC shocked Bachelor Nation this morning when the broadcast network unveiled Arie Luyendyk Jr. as its next “Bachelor” star. So, you know, not Peter Kraus, the “Bachelorette” alum that everybody expected and seemingly wanted.

That choice has the Twitterverse generally confused and disappointed. Mix in a little outrage, and you’ve got this morning’s top trending topic on the social media platform.

See some choice reactions — and great memes — below.

Also Read: 'Bachelor' Shocks Fans With Season 22 Pick

"Your next star of #TheBachelor is Arie Luyendyk Jr!" pic.twitter.com/rucxiutOZM

— Justin Kirkland (@justinkirkland4) September 7, 2017

What you ordered VS What you get #TheBachelor ???? pic.twitter.com/hRRXRBEl1u

— Ashley Pham (@ashleyleanh) September 7, 2017

All the women that signed up for #TheBachelor because they thought it'd be Peter: pic.twitter.com/8ljy5VC0Te

— Bach Bants (@JordanOnDWTS) September 7, 2017

this lady representing the whole of Bachelor Nation right now #TheBachelor pic.twitter.com/FVcKVia71h

— Bach Bants (@JordanOnDWTS) September 7, 2017

All of #bachelornation rn ???? #thebachelor pic.twitter.com/K1TxOE8nnW

— Hannah Young (@uhhuhhannah) September 7, 2017

Me when they revealed #TheBachelor pic.twitter.com/hS7j0q6ueV

— Shayla Smith (@shaylaasmith) September 7, 2017

"I'm so excited to watch Arie as #TheBachelor " …is what I would have said 5 years ago… pic.twitter.com/C5rV3xNJ9B

— The Bachelor Lady (@BachelorLady) September 7, 2017

Could not be more underwhelmed. So many options and ????#TheBachelor pic.twitter.com/Bxf5OoteSu

— Samantha Elizabeth (@samxo) September 7, 2017

Me after seeing who #TheBachelor is pic.twitter.com/IFLYRgtXKl

— amanda marie (@uhhhhmanduhh) September 7, 2017

If you think we're all disappointed, imagine the people who signed up to be a contestant thinking it'd be Peter, Wells or Eric! #thebachelor

— Amanda (@gallagal266) September 7, 2017

Also Read: Ratings: Shorter 'Bachelor in Paradise' Drags ABC Down

But, hey, at least one Twitter user likes the choice! And she just-so happens to be a former “Bachelor” contestant herself.

Here’s what Season 15’s Ashley Spivey posted this morning:

If you are not excited about @ariejr as #thebachelor, I encourage you to watch @EmilyMaynard's season and get back to me. #kissingbandit

— Ashley Spivey (@AshleySpivey) September 7, 2017

43 Summer TV Premieres Ranked by Total Viewers (Photos)

To-date, the Big 4 broadcast networks have premiered 43 summer shows: Here's how they all rank.

(All Nielsen numbers in this study are Live + Same Day TV ratings, and include viewers 2 and older.)

Also Read: The 22 Lowest-Rated Shows to Get Renewed Last Season (Photos)
Rank: 43
Show: "American Grit"
Network: Fox
Total Viewers: 1.114 million

Also Read: 25 Top-Rated TV Shows of 2016-17 Season (Photos)
Fox
Rank: 42
Show: "Still Star-Crossed"
Net: ABC
Total Viewers: 2.288 million

Also Read: Ludacris-Hosted ‘Fear Factor’ Hands MTV Its Highest-Rated Series Premiere in 2 Years
ABC
Rank: 41
Show: "In an Instant"
Net: ABC
Total Viewers: 2.519 million

Also Read: This Show Is Guilty of Being the Lowest-Rated on Broadcast TV
ABC
Rank: 40
Show: "Superhuman"
Net: Fox
Total Viewers: 2.610 million

Also Read: 10 Highest-Rated New Broadcast TV Series of 2016-2017 Season (Photos)
Fox
Rank: 39
Show: "Somewhere Between"
Net: ABC
Total Viewers: 2.905 million

Also Read: Comic-Con 2017: The Winners and Losers (Photos)
ABC
Rank: 38
Show: "To Tell The Truth"
Net: ABC
Total Viewers: 2.942 million

Also Read: ‘Pink Slime’ and 5 More Legal Fights Over Food Insults (Photos)
ABC
Rank: 37
Show: "Zoo"
Net: CBS
Total Viewers: 2.986 million

Also Read: Ratings: Macy’s Fourth of July Fireworks Fizzle Out From 2016
CBS
Rank: 36
Show: "Boy Band"
Net: ABC
Total Viewers: 2.995 million

Also Read: Johnny Depp’s Year-Plus of Despair: From Divorce to Dog Drama to His ‘Bad Joke’ (Photos)
ABC
Rank: 35
Show: "Love Connection"
Net: Fox
Total Viewers: 3.292 million

Also Read: 21 Best-Rated Broadcast Entertainment Series of 2016 (Photos)
Fox
Rank: 34
Show: "The F Word"
Net: Fox
Total Viewers: 3.332 million

Also Read: 10 Lowest-Rated New Broadcast TV Series of 2016-2017 Season (Photos)
Fox
Rank: 33
Show: "Spartan: Ultimate Team Challenge"
Net: NBC
Total Viewers: 3.454 million

Also Read: 25 Highest Rated Broadcast TV Shows of 2015-2016 Season (Photos)
NBC
Rank: 32
Show: "So You Think You Can Dance"
Net: Fox
Total Viewers: 3.559 million

Also Read: Here’s the Best- and Worst-Rated TV Show on Each Network After 1 Month (Photos)
Fox
Rank: 31
Show: "Midnight, Texas"
Net: NBC
Total Viewers: 3.571 million

Also Read: 17 Stars Who Went to Comic-Con in Disguise, From Justin Timberlake to Lupita Nyong’o (Photos)
NBC
Rank: 30
Show: "The Night Shift"
Net: NBC
Total Viewers: 3.591 million

Also Read: ‘Game of Thrones': Who Will Sit on the Iron Throne, According to Oddsmakers (Photos)
NBC
Rank: 29
Show: "Beat Shazam"
Net: Fox
Total Viewers: 3.643 million

Also Read: 20 Highest-Rated Broadcast TV Shows of Summer 2016 (Photos)
Fox
Rank: 28
Show: "MasterChef"
Net: Fox
Total Viewers: 3.666 million

Also Read: ‘Dr Oz’ Just Hit a New All-Time Ratings Low
Fox
Rank: 27
Show: "Hollywood Game Night"
Net: NBC
Total Viewers: 3.799 million

Also Read: ‘Glow': 10 Most Relatable One-Liners in Netflix’s Women Wrestlers Series (Photos)
NBC
Rank: 26
Show: "Bachelor in Paradise" (Tuesday)
Net: ABC
Total Viewers: 3.880 million

Also Read: ‘Bachelor in Paradise’ Star DeMario Jackson Feels ‘Vindicated,’ Admits Suicide ‘Crossed My Mind’
ABC
Rank: 25
Show: "The Gong Show"
Net: ABC
Total Viewers: 3.894 million

Also Read: ‘Power': 7 Main Characters Ranked by How Shady They Are (Photos)
ABC
Rank: 24
Show: "The Carmichael Show"
Net: NBC
Total Viewers: 4.011 million

Also Read: Why NBC Will Win Its 7th Straight Summer in TV Ratings
NBC
Rank: 23
Show: "What Would You Do?"
Net: ABC
Total Viewers: 4.033 million

Also Read: BET Awards 2017: Red Carpet Arrivals, From Queen Latifah to Tyrese Gibson (Photos)
ABC
Rank: 22
Show: "Marlon"
Net: NBC
Total Viewers: 4.045 million

Also Read: ‘Game of Thrones': Key Events in the Series So Far (Photos)
NBC
Rank: 21
Show: "Candy Crush"
Net: CBS
Total Viewers: 4.133 million

Also Read: ‘Twin Peaks': All the Big Questions We Have Through Part 9 (Photos)
CBS
Rank: 20
Show: "Battle of the Network Stars"
Net: ABC
Total Viewers: 4.141 million

Also Read: ABC’s ‘In an Instant’ Is Summer’s Lowest-Rated Broadcast TV Show
ABC
Rank: 19
Show: "The Wall"
Net: NBC
Total Viewers: 4.494 million

Also Read: Harry Potter’s 20th Anniversary: 15 Magical Facts (Photos)
NBC
Rank: 18
Show: "Downward Dog"
Net: ABC
Total Viewers: 4.672 million

Also Read: 9 New Summer Shows and 1 Returning Series Worth Watching (Photos)
ABC
Rank: 17
Show: "Saturday Night Live: Weekend Update Summer Edition"
Net: NBC
Total Viewers: 4.705 million

Also Read: ‘Weekend Update: Summer Edition’ – Kenan Thompson’s LaVar Ball Is ‘Black Trump’ (Video)
NBC
Rank: 16
Show: "Salvation"
Net: CBS
Total Viewers: 4.897 million

Also Read: Netflix in August: What’s Coming and What to Watch Before It’s Gone (Photos)
CBS
Rank: 15
Show: "Bachelor in Paradise" (Monday)
Net: ABC
Total Viewers: 5.094 million

Also Read: Jerry Lewis: A Career in Pictures (Photos)
ABC
Rank: 14
Show: "Big Brother" (Sunday)
Net: CBS
Total Viewers: 5.156 million

Also Read: ‘America’s Got Talent’ Just Broke a Reality Ratings Record (Exclusive)
CBS
Rank: 13
Show: "48 Hours: NCIS"
Net: CBS
Total Viewers: 5.266 million

Also Read: Here’s How Much Fox News Is Hurting Without Bill O’Reilly
CBS
Rank: 12
Show: "American Ninja Warrior"
Net: NBC
Total Viewers: 5.361 million

Also Read: Sean Hannity Pulls a Rachel Maddow, Reaps Huge Ratings for Twitter Bait-and-Switch
NBC
Rank: 11
Show: "Big Brother" (Thursday)
Net: CBS
Total Viewers: 5.367 million

Also Read: Jamie Horowitz Leaves Behind (Relatively) Big Fox Sports 1 Ratings Growth
CBS
Rank: 10
Show: "The $100,000 Pyramid"
Net: ABC
Total Viewers: 5.544 million

Also Read: Here’s How Crucial Sean Hannity Is to Fox News
ABC
Rank: 9
Show: "The Bachelorette"
Net: ABC
Total Viewers: 5.661 million

Also Read: NBC Clinches First Place in TV Season’s Primetime Ratings for 3rd Time in 4 Years
ABC
Rank: 8
Show: "Big Brother" (Wednesday)
Net: CBS
Total Viewers: 5.883 million

Also Read: Ratings: CBS’ ‘Candy Crush’ Has Pretty Sweet Premiere at 9
CBS
Rank: 7
Show: "Funderdome"
Net: ABC
Total Viewers: 6.148 million

Also Read: Fox News Tops HGTV, Nickelodeon as Most-Watched Cable Network
ABC
Rank: 6
Show: "Sunday Night With Megyn Kelly"
Net: NBC
Total Viewers: 6.197 million

Also Read: Stephen Colbert’s ‘Late Show’ Tops ‘Tonight Show’ in Total Viewers for Sept-May Season
NBC
Rank: 5
Show: "Celebrity Family Feud"
Net: ABC
Total Viewers: 7.026 million

Also Read: 18 British Sitcoms You Can Stream Right Now (Photos)
ABC
Rank: 4
Show: "Little Big Shots: Forever Young"
Net: NBC
Total Viewers: 7.424 million

Also Read: ‘Pretty Little Liars’ Finale: First Look at Aria’s Wedding (Photos)
NBC
Rank: 3
Show: "Little Big Shots"
Net: NBC
Total Viewers: 7.452 million

Also Read: 13 Most-Watched Fox News Shows Since Tucker Carlson Replaced Bill O’Reilly (Photos)
NBC
Rank: 2
Show: "World of Dance"
Net: NBC
Total Viewers: 9.713 million

Also Read: ‘Twin Peaks': All the Big Questions We Have After Part 6 (Photos)
NBC
Rank: 1
Show: "America's Got Talent"
Net: NBC
Total Viewers: 12.320 million

Also Read: ‘Orange Is the New Black': 22 Characters Ranked From Worst to Best (Photos)
NBC
Good thing we left The CW out of this study, right "Whose Line Is It Anyway?" and "Hooten & the Lady"?

Also Read: TV Shows You Should Binge-Watch Right Now, From ‘OITNB’ to ‘Better Call Saul’ (Photos)
CW

1 of 45

“The Bachelorette” doesn’t even sniff the Top 5 this year

To-date, the Big 4 broadcast networks have premiered 43 summer shows: Here's how they all rank.

(All Nielsen numbers in this study are Live + Same Day TV ratings, and include viewers 2 and older.)

Also Read: The 22 Lowest-Rated Shows to Get Renewed Last Season (Photos)

View In Gallery

Keep
Reading...

Looks like you’re enjoying reading

Keep reading by creating
a free account or logging in.

Continue