You don’t steal a man’s Thanksgiving dessert — you just don’t. On Tuesday, someone on the “Brooklyn Nine-Nine” squad is going down for absconding with Captain Holt’s (Andre Braugher) baked goods.

Every year, Holt and Kevin (guest star Marc Evan Jackson) buy a very special holiday pie. Tonight, when it goes missing, the big boss man interrogates the entire precinct to find out who the culprit is.

Watch TheWrap‘s exclusive sneak-peek video from the whodunnit half-hour above.

Also Read: 'LA to Vegas', 'The Resident' Get January Premiere Dates From Fox

Elsewhere in the borough, Jake (Andy Samberg) and Amy (Melissa Fumero) attempt to get their parents to bond over Thanksgiving dinner, but this first holiday as a family doesn’t go so well.

The “Two Turkeys” episode of “Brooklyn Nine-Nine” airs tonight at 9:30 p.m. ET/PT on Fox. Bradley Whitford, Katey Sagal, Jimmy Smits and Bertila Damas also guest star.

Cancellation Watch: 9 TV Shows That Likely Won't Last Beyond This Season (Photos)

Sure, it's a bit early in the fall broadcast TV season to declare a series dead -- unless that show is called "Ten Days in the Valley" or "Me, Myself & I" -- but the inquiring minds need to know what's in line to get the boot.

There are a number of factors that go into cancelling or renewing a series: costs, ratings, ownership, contracts, stars, I.P. -- the list still goes on from there.
Show: "The Toy Box"
Net: ABC
18-49 rating: 0.4

The "Shark Tank"-for-kids show is one toy that ABC should have never unwrapped. (Ratings are from Nielsen's "most current" metric, which includes one week's worth of DVR viewing where available.)

Also Read: 31 Highest and Lowest-Rated Shows of the Fall TV Season So Far (Photos)
ABC
Show: "Ten Days in the Valley"
Net: ABC
18-49 rating: 0.7

OK, so "Ten Days" was set up as a limited series, but we all know by now that you can add "...unless it's a hit" to the end of that descriptor. This one definitely was not, and has already been banished to Saturdays.

Also Read: 10 Lowest-Rated TV Shows of Summer 2017 (Photos)
ABC
Show: "The Exorcist"
Net: Fox
18-49 rating: 0.6

Couple things: Fox owns "The Exorcist." Both the studio and network are run by the same pair of executives. But it's time to exorcise this Friday series, not resurrect it.

Also Read: 11 Top-Rated TV Shows of Summer 2017 (Photos)
Fox
Show: "Marvel's Inhumans"
Net: ABC
18-49 rating: 1.0

From its weird IMAX rollout to Medusa's awful CGI wig, this show was a disaster from the get-go. When asked by TheWrap for a phone interview tied to the show's fall finale, ABC said no one in the cast was available -- that's never a good sign.

Also Read: ‘Judge Judy’ Wins 2016-17 Syndicated Season, Its Fourth in a Row
ABC
Show: "Once Upon a Time"
Net: ABC
18-49 rating: 1.0

Once Upon a Time, this show was a hit. Now it barely has any of the original cast members left, and even the creators are displeased with their rebooted fairy tale's recent reception.

Also Read: ABC’s ‘In an Instant’ Is Summer’s Lowest-Rated Broadcast TV Show
ABC
Show: "Me, Myself & I"
Net: CBS
18-49 rating: 1.3

Bobby Moynihan should have stuck with "Saturday Night Live." But he didn't, and the casting of a 6'4" John Larroquette to play the older version of a 5'8" Moynihan made absolutely no sense. CBS has already pulled this show from its schedule.

Also Read: The 22 Lowest-Rated Shows to Get Renewed Last Season (Photos)
CBS
Show: "Brooklyn Nine-Nine"
Net: Fox
18-49 rating: 1.2

Though it pains us to say, this very good sitcom is probably about to be released on parole. It's still very funny, but the Andy Samberg comedy isn't owned by Fox, which doesn't help its case. Plus, "Brooklyn's" "live" rating should be considered a felony.

Also Read: 20 Lowest-Rated TV Shows of 2016-17 Season (Photos)
Fox
Show: "9JKL"
Net: CBS
18-49 rating: 1.4

Not a good show, an even worse title -- don't let the "Big Bang Theory"-boosted rating fool you. Cute only goes so far.

Also Read: 25 Top-Rated TV Shows of 2016-17 Season (Photos)
CBS
Show: "Great News"
Net: NBC
18-49 rating: 1.1

We've got good news and bad news, "Great News": On the plus side, you're owned by NBC and have garnered generally favorable reviews; on the negative end of the spectrum... your ratings. IF the sitcom returns, that can be chalked up to two words: "Tina. Fey."

Also Read: 18 New Fall TV Shows Ranked by Premiere Viewers, From ‘SWAT’ to ‘The Good Doctor’ (Photos)
NBC
Consider yourself on notice (and on the bubble, at best), "Kevin (Probably) Saves the World," "Last Man on Earth" and "Wisdom of the Crowd." We'll see how the rest of the 2017-18 season shakes out.

Also Read: ‘Stranger Things 2’ Debut Drew More Viewers Than ‘The Walking Dead’ Season 8 Premiere
CBS/ABC/Fox

1 of 11

Don’t even try for a finale cliffhanger, “9JKL”

Sure, it's a bit early in the fall broadcast TV season to declare a series dead -- unless that show is called "Ten Days in the Valley" or "Me, Myself & I" -- but the inquiring minds need to know what's in line to get the boot.

There are a number of factors that go into cancelling or renewing a series: costs, ratings, ownership, contracts, stars, I.P. -- the list still goes on from there.

View In Gallery

‘Brooklyn Nine-Nine': Holt Interrogates Squad in Missing Thanksgiving Pie Caper (Exclusive Video)

Cancellation Watch: 9 TV Shows That Likely Won't Last Beyond This Season (Photos)

Ryan Reynolds and Will Ferrell to Star in Musical Remake of ‘A Christmas Carol’

Julie Andrews to Receive the 48th AFI Life Achievement Award

Antonio Brown Cut by New England Patriots Amid Rape Accusations

‘The Climb’ Co-Writers and Stars Michael Covino and Kyle Marvin on the Adultery Tale’s Inspiration | Video

Julie Delpy Was Inspired by Polish Auteur Krzysztof Kieslowski For Her Drama ‘My Zoe’ (Video)

Cancellation Watch: 9 TV Shows That Likely Won't Last Beyond This Season (Photos)

Related Content