Curbed Los Angeles issued a broad correction to a blog post more than nine years after the fact, conceding that the website had been duped by noted media manipulator Ryan Holiday.
“This snippet of an article was published in 2009, centuries ago in internet years, and the original gist of it has been lost to time,” reads an editor’s note almost as long as the original post.
“In the year 2018, a concerned reader wrote in to say that this reader tip was a hoax, one of many perpetuated by a person named Ryan Holiday, who later published a book about all these fibs to media outlets. Do with that information what you will!”
The story of this week’s correction begins back in 2009, when Holiday vandalized a series of billboards in Los Angeles advertising the film version of Tucker Max’s “I Hope They Serve Beer in Hell.” Holiday, however, was no petty criminal, but a flack who had been ordered by Max to gin up publicity for the flick.
“My campaign for ‘I Hope They Serve Beer in Hell’ began with vandalizing the billboards. The graffiti was designed to bait two specific sites, Curbed Los Angeles and Mediabistro’s FishbowlLA. When I sent them photos of my work under the fake name Evan Meyer, they both quickly picked it up,” Holiday explained in his book “Trust Me, I’m Lying,” first published in 2012. “Curbed LA began their post by using my email verbatim.”
In the book, Holiday noted the difficulty of correcting false or misleading news stories on blogs.
“It’s been more than five years since this happened. I included it in the first and second editions of the book. I’ve told the story on NPR’s “On the Media” and dozens of other outlets and as of this writing that story on Curbed.com (owned by Vox Media) is still there and still uncorrected,” Holiday also noted in a footnote of the book’s most recent edition.
The author of the original piece, Dakota Smith, now a reporter at the Los Angeles Times, declined to comment on the issue, referring TheWrap to Vox Media. A rep for the company initially told TheWrap they would look into the matter but then proceeded to ignore multiple subsequent phone and emailed follow ups.
The editor’s note was only affixed to the piece after two inquiries to Curbed editor-in-chief Kelsey Keith this week neither of which were directly responded to.
“It only took a decade!” Holiday told TheWrap after learning of the correction.
9 Times New York Times Editorial Made Everyone Freak Out
Bari Weiss: We're All Fascists Now
The New York Times opinion editor set the Internet ablaze after going after college students who she said were trying to shut down free speech. Critics pointed to Weiss mistakenly linking two fake ANTIFA Twitter accounts
MSNBC
David Brooks: 'Girl I Want Your Body'
New York Times Op-Ed columnist David Brooks offered his spin on the MeToo movement in November. But his attempt to speak the language of sex and passion led him to write some lines like "girl I want your body" and "sex is a gold nugget" and the Internet went nuts.
Getty
Bret Stephens' "A Defense, of Sorts, for Harvey Weinstein"
The October, 2017 piece was actually titled "Weinstein and Our Culture of Enablers," but Stephens couldn't resist throwing in the trollish alternative headline see above into a tweeted description of the article -- which promptly precipitated an Internet meltdown
YouTube
David Brooks Urges "Respect to Gun Owners" After Parkland, Florida Massacre
David Brooks set passions aflame after urging "respect" for gun owners after 17 children were killed at a school shooting in Parkland, Florida. "So if you want to stop school shootings it's not enough just to vent and march. It's necessary to let people from Red America lead the way, and to show respect to gun owners at all points," he wrote.
Getty
Quinn "Been Friends with Various Neo-Nazis" Norton
The New York Times got more than they bargained for when they hired tech writer Quinn Norton. Almost immediately after the news was announced old tweets began to emerge including where Norton said she had "been friends with various neo-nazis" and used the N word. The Times cut her loose just hours after she was hired.
YouTube
Bari Weiss Attacks Aziz Ansari Accuser: 'I'll Get Crushed for This'
Weiss risked more wrath on the set of "Morning Joe" in January after blasting a woman who accused comedian Aziz Ansari of sexual misconduct. "It's called bad sex," she told Joe and Mika. "I'll get crushed for saying this."
TheWrap
Bari Weiss Quotes Hamilton: 'Immigrants: We Get the Job Done"
Anti-Weiss Internet mobs were set ablaze after she tweeted out "Immigrants: we get the job done," in response to Olympian Mirai Nagasu's triple axel. Nagasu was born in California to immigrant parents and Twitter furiously dragged her for not paying sufficient deference to the decision.
Getty
James Bennet Diversifies the Times Opinion Pages
Editorial Page Editor James Bennet has said his mission is to broaden editorial diversity on the Times newsroom. The initiative has often been rocky and the paper has been beset by online criticism of hiring choices, and targeted leaks by Times employees unhappy with his changes.
YouTube
David Brooks Sandwich-Shames Less Educated Friend
Perhaps most egregious of all in the mind of Internet warriors was Brooks' confession in a July, 2017 column that he once took a friend "with only a high school degree" into a gourmet sandwich shop but decided to pull a quick switch for Mexican food after, so he said, she appeared overwhelmed by words like Soppressata and Capicollo.
Creative Commons
1 of 9
Most of the recent fire and fury comes from the paper’s editorial pages
Bari Weiss: We're All Fascists Now
The New York Times opinion editor set the Internet ablaze after going after college students who she said were trying to shut down free speech. Critics pointed to Weiss mistakenly linking two fake ANTIFA Twitter accounts