Former Equifax CEO Richard F. Smith received the opposite of a hero’s welcome while addressing a congressional committee on Tuesday, with representatives bashing the exec for the credit giant’s “unacceptable” hack that left nearly half the U.S. population vulnerable to identity fraud.
Smith blamed the data breach — which compromised the social security numbers, addresses, and birth dates of 145 million Americans — on a “human error,” where an unnamed employee failed to patch its security system, despite the fix being available for months before the hack.
“So does that mean that that individual knew the software was there,” asked Rep. Greg Walden, “and it needed to be patched, and did not communicate that to the team that did the patching?”
“Talk about ham-handed responses, this is simply unacceptable,” said Walden, the chairman of the Energy and Commerce Committee. He went on to say the bungled operation was “like the guards at Fort Knox forgot to lock the doors.”
But there was plenty of slamming to go around, with the committee members ready and willing to tee off on perhaps the one company more unpopular than Congress right now.
“I worry that your job today is about damage control: to put a happy face on your firm’s disgraceful actions and then depart with a golden parachute,” said New Mexico Rep. Ben Ray Lujan. “Unfortunately, if fraudsters destroy my constituents’ savings and financial futures, there’s no golden parachute awaiting them.”
Smith — who retired last week — repeatedly apologized for the hack during his remarks. “I’m here today to say to each and every person affected by this breach I’m truly and deeply sorry for what happened,” said Smith.
His cries for absolution were brushed off by the committee, however.
“You’re just required to notify everybody and say, ‘So sorry, so sad,'” said Rep. Joe Barton of Texas. “We can have this hearing every year from now on if we don’t do anything to change the current system.”
The ex-exec was questioned on the three high-ranking Equifax employees that sold millions of dollars worth of stock only days after the company noticed the hack on July 29. The company did not publicly acknowledge the breach until early September. Smith said they had no idea about the breach when they sold their shares. “I don’t know exactly the date they were informed, but to the best of my knowledge they had no knowledge at the time.”
Several committee members discussed the potential need to regulate or shut down Equifax altogether. “When restaurants fail regular health inspections, they’re shut down,” said Rep. Gene Green of Texas.” Others pointed to the everlasting threat hacked consumers will now face — with their social security information able to be held for years before being sold on the black market.
The three-hour skewering did little to assuage committee members, with many calling for further hearings with other Equifax execs. Check out the link below if you want to see some Congress-on-CEO lambasting.
The Scene at TheGrill 2017: TheWrap's Media Leadership Conference
Co-Chairmen and CEO's of Fox Television Group Gary Newman and Dana Walden, and John Singleton.
Getty Images
TheWrap's annual TheGrill media conference took place at the Montage Beverly Hills on Oct. 2 and Oct. 3.
Getty Images
TheWrap's CEO and editor-in-chief Sharon Waxman greets attendees at the 8th annual TheGrill conference.
Getty Images
Audience members listen to panels on the first day of TheGrill.
Getty Images
Sky Moore, partner at Greenberg Glusker, Cindy Lin, CEO of Infotainment China, and President of DMG Entertainment, Chris Fenton at TheWrap's annual TheGrill conference.
Getty Images
David Grinberg, partner at Sidley Austin LLP, speaks onstage at TheWrap's 8th Annual TheGrill.
Getty Images
Stanley Rosen, professor of political science at USC, speaks with Sharon Waxman on stage.
Getty Images
Catherine Zhang of Youku Tudou and Colin Brady of CAA discuss streaming in China with TheWrap's Matt Pressberg.
Ted Soqui
Vicki Beck and Jan Pinkava speak with Sharon Waxman on stage.
Ted Soqui
The Montage in Beverly Hills.
Getty Images
Attendees gather around the lunch buffet at TheGrill on Monday.
Getty Images
Stanley Rosen, Matt Pressberg and Cindy Lin at TheGrill.
Getty Images
Ted Schilowitz of Paramount Pictures speaks at TheGrill.
Getty Images
Attendees gather at The Montage for TheWrap's annual TheGrill conference.
Getty Images
Sharon Waxman with Albie Hecht.
Getty Images
Sharon Waxman with speakers at TheGrill.
Getty Images
Kathleen Grace and Robert Goldberg speak on a panel during TheGrill.
Getty Images
Audience members of TheGrill conference converse during a break.
Ted Soqui
Virtual Reality panel at TheGrill.
Ted Soqui
Managing director and media and technology analyst at BTIG Rich Greenfield discusses the future of media with Sharon Waxman.
Ted Soqui
Gary Newman and Dana Walden speak with Sharon Waxman on stage.
Ted Soqui
Michael Bloom, Robert Goldberg, Kathleen Grace, Alec Shankman and Chris M. Williams speak about multimedia platforms at TheGrill.
Getty Images
ILMxLAB's Vicki Beck and Google Spotlight Stories' Jan Pinkava talk about VR at TheGrill.
Getty Images
Director John Singleton before his panel at the end of TheGrill's first day.
Getty Images
Audience members talk during a break at TheGrill.
Getty Images
Director of International Content Cooperation of Youku Tudou Inc., Catherine Zhang, attends TheGrill.
Getty Images
Founding Partner of MacInnes Scott, John MacInnes, attends TheWrap's media conference on Monday.
Getty Images
UCLA's Elizabeth Joye Buda and Kate Pierce attend TheWrap's TheGrill.
Getty Images
The audience watches a panel at TheWrap's media and technology conference, TheGrill.
Getty Images
TheWrap's film reporter Matt Pressberg on a panel with Co-Founder and EVP of WEVR, Anthony Batt, Founding Partner of MacInnes Scott, John MacInnes and Paramount Pictures' Ted Schilowitz.
Getty Images
TheWrap's Tim Molloy speaks with "Boyz N The Hood" director John Singleton
Getty Images
Cocktail party on the terrace of The Montage in Beverly Hills
Getty Images
Sharon Waxman and TheWrap team
Getty Images
Invar CEO Elizabeth Koshi, John Singleton, and ICM's Crystal Mais at TheGrill
Getty Images
Raymond Reed and Sabrina Taylor
Getty Images
Attendees at TheGrill cocktail party.
Getty Images
Weather Channel's Dave Shull discusses climate change with Sharon Waxman.
Ted Soqui
Producers Nina Jacobson and Darren Throop with Sharon Waxman
Ted Soqui
Adi Sideman at TheGrill
Ted Soqui
Tobias Quesser at TheGrill
Ted Soqui
Franklin Leonard discusses diversity at TheGrill
Ted Soqui
M and A panel at TheGrill
Ted Soqui
Paramount distribution head Megan Colligan and Lionsgate Marketing SVP Thai Randolph
Ted Soqui
TheGrill's Innovators Panel
Ted Soqui
TheGrill's Innovators Panel
Ted Soqui
DreamWorks founder Jeffrey Katzenberg and Sharon Waxman
Ted Soqui
mitu President Beatriz Acevado
Ted Soqui
Ted Soqui
1 of 48
Entertainment, media and technology converge at TheWrap’s 8th Annual Grill Conference at the Montage Beverly Hills
Co-Chairmen and CEO's of Fox Television Group Gary Newman and Dana Walden, and John Singleton.