During an event last month promoting her new book, “Be Fierce: Stop Harassment and Take Your Power Back,” former Fox News host Gretchen Carlson took a pointed shot at a workplace institution — Human Resources.
Despite its traditional role as a mediator of workplace complaints, Carlson blasted HR departments at Fox and many other large corporations as ineffective.
“I actually believe that reporting sexual harassment should go to a different part of the company. In fact, it shouldn’t even be a part of the company,” she said. “Remember who is signing the paycheck, because that’s who you’re beholden to. And if the harasser is the boss, then forget it. You as the employee have no chance.”
As the political and media worlds deal with near daily allegations of sexual misconduct, HR has emerged as a familiar boogeyman, at best looking the other way and at worst actively enabling the behavior they are supposed to prevent. In many cases, individuals like Mark Halperin at ABC News and Bill O’Reilly at Fox News who have become the targets of sexual misconduct accusations never received a single HR complaint.
“Sexual harassment claims are obviously amongst the most sensitive for all parties involved. The stress that an employee has about reporting it cannot be underestimated,” Glen Loveland, a veteran HR manager now working for China Central Television, told TheWrap. “It really is up to HR to create an environment in which employees feel safe to speak with them.”
Loveland added that too many industry professionals were disconnected from the day-to-day realities of employees.
“HR leaders have a responsibility to be more visible in the workplace. Building those relationships and bridges is so important to help ward off issues in the first place,” he noted.
There are other issues too. During an appearance on “Late Night With Seth Meyers,” another former Fox News host, Megyn Kelly, summed up the dilemma many women face when deciding whether to file a complaint.
“Even if HR is a real option, it doesn’t always go your way,” Kelly told Meyers during an October appearance. “If you take a shot at the king you better kill him, you’ve heard that saying. If you don’t win this showdown, you know what’s going to happen to you.”
Indeed without the a smoking gun — damning evidence like emails or text messages — too many HR complaints devolve into a he said, she said argument with no end result except the residue of bad blood. In many cases, too, HR professionals fail to close the loop by explaining to accusers how their original complaint was resolved.
Rob Toole, a partner with the HR outsourcing firm, Kona HR Consulting, agreed with Kelly’s assessment.
“The big issue is, if you go to HR and you want to make a complaint against Bill O’Reilly, the first thing you tell the person is, ‘We have to tell Bill O’Reilly you are making complaint,'” said Toole, citing procedures required by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.
In Toole’s experience, that disclosure to the accused dissuades roughly half of employees from filing complaints in the first place.
Failure to “kill the king” also raises the real issue of retaliation from the company or the accused.
While workplace retaliation over sexual harassment charges is specifically forbidden by the 1964 Civil Rights Act, it does happen, with Toole and Kelly both saying it can be conducted in subtle ways that are almost impossible to prove.
Megyn Kelly calls Trump out on women Trump famously feuded former anchor Kelly after she asked him a tough question at a Republican primary debate about derogatory statements he's made about women. Trump took it personally, judging by his response on Twitter and in interviews. He later famously said Kelly must have had "blood coming out of her wherever" regarding the question. Watch the debate question here.
Kelly to Trump: "Facts matter" Trump kept hammering at Kelly on Twitter and elsewhere. When he called her out for not using the IBT poll when he was leading the Republican primary field, Kelly rebuked him with a tweet showing she did use the poll. "Facts matter," she wrote.
Fox mocks Trump with statement on debate skipping poll After polled his Twitter followers to see if he should drop out of a Fox-hosted Republican primary debate, Fox responded artfully with a sarcastic statement that it had learned from "secret" sources Trump might be treated unfairly as president by foreign leaders.
Bill O'Reilly calls out Trump's tweet with totally wrong stats "The O'Reilly Factor" grilled Trump in a Nov. 2015 interview about his tweet that erroneously said black people killed whites at a rate of 81 percent, while whites kill blacks at a rate of 15 percent. O'Reilly told Trump, "You shouldn't tweet." Trump did not take that advice.
Chris Wallace bucks Trump calling media "enemy of the public" After his press conference in January 2017, Trump continued his attack on media he doesn't like on Twitter. Anchor Chris Wallace wasn't having it on "Fox & Friends." Wallace said Trump's comments "crossed an important line" and said they were dangerous.
Wallace says the media is too easy on Trump In an interview with TheWrap, Wallace said he thinks Sunday political shows in particular should be tougher on Trump. "I think if anything, the media has treated him too well. By that I mean they’ve allowed him to play by different rules." Read the full interview.
O'Reilly tells Trump Putin is "a killer" In a February interview, O'Reilly brought up Trump's apparent refusal to criticize Vladimir Putin, calling the Russian president "a killer." Trump famously responded by saying, "What, you think our country is so innocent?" Watch it here.
Smith wails on Trump's refusal to talk about Russia hacks Nobody on Fox hits Trump harder than Shep Smith. "We have a right to know… You call us ‘fake news’ and put us down like children for asking questions on behalf of the American people." Watch it here.
Neil Cavuto tells Trump he's the problem, not mainstream media Responding to Trump's tweet claiming the mainstream media wants him off social media, Cavuto called out Trump for losing track of his own agenda. "Mr. President, it is not the fake news media that's your problem, it's you," Cavuto said. Watch it here.
Smith blasts Trump administration on Russia: "Lie after lie after lie" Shep Smith was at it again following the news breaking about Donald Trump Jr.'s meeting with a Kremlin-linked lawyer. He took the Trump administration to task for its many lies about meetings with Russia, including Jared Kushner failing to report the meeting on his security clearance forms. "My grandmother used to say, 'What a tangled web we weave when first we try to deceive,'" Smith declared on air, leaving fellow anchor Chris Wallace speechless. Watch it here.
Eboni K. Williams slams Trump's remarks about Charlottesville
Following the Unite the Right rally in which a counter-protester was murdered, Trump blamed "both sides" for the violence. On "Fox News Specialists," host Eboni K. Williams took Trump to task for not standing up to white nationalists and white supremacists who support him, calling his initial remarks about the rally "cowardly and dangerous."
Brian Kilmeade calls Trump tweet "ridiculous" blaming U.S. for Russia relations
In a rare sight in the lead up to the summit in Helsinki between Trump and Putin, Trump tweeted, "Our relationship with Russia has NEVER been worse thanks to many years of U.S. foolishness and stupidity and now, the Rigged Witch Hunt!" On "Fox and Friends," a show that has been extremely favorable to Trump (he even calls in), host Brian Kilmeade said of the tweet, "That’s by far the most ridiculous tweet of late, and that is insulting to past administrations. He can’t be saying that going into the Russian summit." Watch the clip here.
Cavuto blasts Trump's performance in Helsinki: "disgusting"
Neil Cavuto took Trump to task more than once after his Helsinki press conference with Putin. When former Deputy Assistant Attorney General Tom Dupree said Trump could have rebuked Putin for his Russia's attack on U.S. elections, Cavuto said, "But he didn’t and that’s what made it disgusting. That’s what made his performance disgusting. I’m sorry, it’s just the only way I feel. It’s not a right or left thing for me, it’s just wrong." Watch it here.
Trish Regan says Trump "should have defended us" against Putin
Fox Business host Trish Regan got mad about Trump's performance on her show "The Intelligence Report." "He should have defended us," she said. "He should have defended his own intelligence community. Or just don’t take the meeting! Don’t go to Helsinki if you can’t look the guy in the eye and tell him what’s what!" Watch it here.
1 of 18
Donald Trump’s favorite network, Fox News, isn’t always rosy on what he says and does, especially when he backs Russia over the U.S. intelligence community