Inside Donald Trump’s First ‘SNL’ Host Gig With Show Writer – And What to Expect Next

“He’s like a comedy character that someone would go, ‘That’s too broad a character,'” Paula Pell tells TheWrap

As controversy swirls around Donald Trump’s upcoming “Saturday Night Live” hosting gig, TheWrap was curious about the impression he left first time he graced the stage at 30 Rockefeller Center.

Paula Pell, a longtime “SNL” staff writer who still contributes to Lorne Michael’s TV mainstay, worked on the show when Trump hosted in April 2004 at the height of his “Apprentice” fame.

Pell, who wrote the script for the upcoming Amy Poehler and Tina Fey movie “Sisters,” detailed her experience with Trump as host — like his “very entertaining, sort of bizarre” character traits, his desire to state the obvious and his very healthy self-esteem.

TheWrap:  In 2004, Donald was an NBC darling so naturally he was asked to host. What were your first impressions?
Paula Pell
: He was a very entertaining, sort of bizarre character that you couldn’t believe. He’s like a comedy character that someone would go, ‘That’s too broad a character.’

And at the time, Darrell Hammond was impersonating Trump.
Yes, a writer named John Lutz and I wrote the Darrell Hammond Trump sketches for a few years. They were actually based on when Trump hosted the first time. When you would give him notes, and he would say, ‘I need you to put that on a card for me!’ And, like, that’s what SNL does. We use cue cards. As if we had not been doing the show for 35 years at the time. We started writing him as Darell telling people the obvious — like, he’d say to the dentist, ‘You need to fix this cavity.’ Yes, he knows.

Was anything off limits for him? Anything he was unwilling to poke fun at in his own life or business?
I think not as long as he was getting laughs. He didn’t have too much of a discerning taste about things. I know he immediately hit the ground running telling us how high the ratings would be. He was very braggy, which  didn’t surprise anybody. At the time, he really was somebody that was tremendously fun because he was so confident. His hair is a virtual work of art. It’s not changed.

I’m sure the election will be prominent in terms of content, but does it change his parameters as host?
It’s a completely different when you’re running for something, I remember with Al Gore, there will be a lot more filters his stuff will go through, as opposed to any other celebrity who might host. It was no holds barred the first time, and the more ridiculous the better. He had a reality show. Now, they’re probably trying to strike a balance. When it gets down to an election year, I think it will start getting a little more humorless. But if any place can take someone and make them funny and at the same time make light of what they are — “SNL” does a beautiful job of that.

“SNL” is not a place for candidates to bring issues and be serious.
There are many times when people come on making fun of themselves. It’s going to be good, and he’s comfortable there in that venue. He’s like a dog at Westminster Dog Show. He’s  got a lot of swirling hair, too. What’s interesting about him is that he has to become more serious — he’s going to need very specific answers to big questions. And as we get farther, it’s going to be really funny or really scary. Like, ‘Oh. He could actually be the candidate.’

Taran Killam plays Trump now, and I think back to what a boon it was for Tina Fey when Sarah Palin came on. Will this just send Taran into the stratosphere?
It’s absolutely the best thing ever to be the person playing someone running. Whether Trump continues to rise in the GOP and actually run, the show can still milk this out for quite a long time. Taran is going to have a really good year. Especially as the person who is most ridiculous? That’s manna from heaven. Also, you get additional viewers who don’t usually watch the show outside an election year.

Trump’s episode of “SNL” airs Saturday November 7. Watch his 2004 monologue here.