Jimmy Kimmel Introduces World to ‘Williamsburg or Gettysburg?’ Beard-Guessing Game (Video)

The rules are simple. Being correct is hard

Modern-day Williamsburg, Brooklyn has some of the thickest beards in American history. Just don’t tell that to Civil War-era Gettysburg.

On Thursday, Jimmy Kimmel introduced the world to his “Williamsburg or Gettysburg?” beard-guessing game. It was an instant hit, and harder then you might think.

At least the rules were simple: Kimmel showed a close-up photo of a beard and his audience had to guess whether it was from the ABC show’s week in the New York City borough or from like 150 years ago on a Pennsylvania battlefield.

Play along with the video above, and be sure to stick around for a special guest appearance.