First Lady Melania Trump scored a partial legal victory on Friday, with a judge shooting down arguments to dismiss the suit.
According to Politico, Montgomery County Circuit Judge Sharon Burrell disagreed with blogger Webster Tarpley’s contention that the suit failed to meet the standard for “actual malice” with regard to public figures.
The judge also rejected an argument by Tarpley’s lawyers that Trump’s suit runs afoul of Maryland’s SLAPP law, which aims to prevent lawsuits brought to intimidate others from speaking out on public matters.
Trump sued Tarpley and the Daily Mail in September, claiming that a story saying that Trump worked for a modeling agency where the models also worked as escorts inaccurately painted her as a sex worker.
“Plaintiff did legitimate and legal modeling work for legitimate business entities and did not work for any ‘gentleman’s club’ or ‘escort’ agencies,'” Trump’s lawsuit reads. “Plaintiff was not a sex worker, escort or prostitute in any way, shape or form.”
“The court finds the plaintiff has stated a claim for defamation,” Burrell said. “The court believes most people, when they hear the words ‘high-end escort’ that describes a prostitute. There could be no more defamatory statement than to call a woman a prostitute.”
Despite the partial early victory, Trump’s claims against the Daily Mail still hang in the balance. An attorney for Mail Media told the court that Maryland is an improper venue for the claims against the Mail. The attorney, Kelli Sager, also contended that Trump is aso suing the Daily Mail’s parent company in London over the escort article.
While those claims are still being weighed, Judge Burrell halted discovery proceedings against the Daily Mail, which retracted its story, possibly suggesting that the claims against the Mail could be dropped in the Maryland case.
Trump’s attorney had no comment for TheWrap on Friday’s ruling.
The First Lady is seeking damages “in an amount in excess of $75,000.”
18 People, Places and Things Donald and Melania Trump Have Threatened To Sue (Photos)
This week, Melania Trump threatened to sue an autistic man who speculated that her and Donald Trump's son, Barron, might be autistic, too. It was at least the 18th lawsuit or threat of a lawsuit since Donald Trump's presidential campaign began. Here are the 18 people, places and things Donald Trump and Melania Trump have sued or threatened to sue.
Getty Images
In a long-winded speech about voter fraud, Trump threatened to sue the U.S. if he did not win the election.
Univision dropped Trump's Miss USA pageant after he said many Mexicans were rapists and criminals. In response, Trump sued, and the network settled for an undisclosed amount.
A British college night club known as Kasbah received a cease-and-desist order and a threat for further legal action after it used Trump's image negatively.
Kasbah Night Club
Melania Trump's lawyers took legal action against the Daily Mail when the publication looked into past suggestions that she was once an escort.
After YouTuber James Hunter posted a now-removed video speculating that Barron Trump might be autistic, Melania Trump threatened a lawsuit. Hunter said he would take down the video.
Tony Schwartz, who authored Trump's "Art of the Deal," described Trump as unfit to be president. So Trump threatened to sue.
Getty Images
During a campaign speech in February, Trump named the Washington Post among many that would be affected by loosening libel laws.
Getty Images
Celebrity chef Geoffrey Zakarian left his job at Donald Trump's D.C. Hotel after Trump's comments against Mexicans. In response, Trump sued, and Zakarian has counter-sued.
Getty Images
Trump threatened to sue the New York Times after it reported that Trump may have avoided federal income taxes for nearly 20 years. The Times' reply is worth reading.
After Sen. Harry Reid encouraged Americans to be strong despite a "sexual predator" becoming president, Trump's campaign manager Kellyanne Conway released a statement that alluded to Trump's intention to sue the senator for his comments.
Donald Trump has the busiest lawyers, believe me. Sad.
This week, Melania Trump threatened to sue an autistic man who speculated that her and Donald Trump's son, Barron, might be autistic, too. It was at least the 18th lawsuit or threat of a lawsuit since Donald Trump's presidential campaign began. Here are the 18 people, places and things Donald Trump and Melania Trump have sued or threatened to sue.