MSNBC Boss Andy Lack Wants to Dump Lawrence O’Donnell for Brian Williams, Insider Says (Exclusive)

Despite O’Donnell’s soaring ratings, insider says network is not negotiating new deal when his contract expires in four weeks

msnbc lawrence o'donnell brian williams
Getty Images

MSNBC chairman Andy Lack is determined to replace prime-time host Lawrence O’Donnell in the 10 p.m. ET time slot with Brian Williams after O’Donnell’s current contract is up in four weeks, a network insider told TheWrap.

O’Donnell’s show, “The Last Word,” has been a ratings hit lately with the red-hot Rachel Maddow serving as its lead-in. As recently as Thursday night, O’Donnell was the second-most watched program in cable news, behind only Maddow. “The Last Word” won its 10 p.m. ET timeslot in both total viewers and the key news demo of adults age 25-54.

At least one insider close to the situation told TheWrap that MSNBC has had only preliminary discussions with O’Donnell’s team to negotiate a new deal — though it is unclear if those talks were initiated since a Sunday HuffPost story questioning the host’s future at the network.

As recently as Saturday, an individual close to the situation said the network had not contacted O’Donnell’s team about a new contract, adding, “I don’t know why Andy is afraid of owning something he’s been planning for two years.”

An MSNBC spokesperson told TheWrap that the network doesn’t comment on ongoing contract negotiations. Asked early Monday if the refusal to comment is confirmation that contract negotiations are indeed ongoing, and the MSNBC spokesperson replied, “Yes.” A rep for WME, which represents O’Donnell, declined to comment.

Lack has taken a large role in rehabilitating Williams’s career, which took a big hit in 2015 when he was removed as anchor of “NBC Nightly News” over revelations he exaggerated stories about his reporting from Iraq and elsewhere. Lack eased him back in as a breaking news anchor on MSNBC once reinstated and eventually giving him the 11 p.m. ET timeslot.

at MSNBC is stunned at Andy’s obliviousness to Brian’s unique glass house of fake news, because of Brian’s exaggerating and lying that got him thrown off NBC,” the MSNBC insider told TheWrap. “If Trump calls NBC fake news and quotes Brian, he will be right. It’s a nuclear bomb in Trump’s hands whenever he wants to use it.”

However, Williams has been hot as well and his numbers will presumably continue to rise if he moves into O’Donnell’s timeslot — which the insider said was Lack’s plan.

“It made no sense to anyone at MSNBC that Brian was worthy of MSNBC but banned from NBC,” the insider said. “Some people think the plan is to get Brian into prime time and in couple years ease Lester Holt into retirement and restore Brian” as anchor of “NBC Nightly News.”

Meanwhile, Holt has been hot, beating ABC’s “World News Tonight” and CBS’ “Evening News” in both total viewers and the key demo of adults age 25-54 last week and landing a news-making interview with President Trump. “NBC Nightly News” also finished 2016 as the most-watched evening newscast, winning all major categories.

O’Donnell became a regular contributor on MSNBC’s “Morning Joe” in 2009, which eventually led to his own show “The Last Word with Lawrence O’Donnell” a year later. Prior to emerging as one of MSNBC’s prime-time stars, O’Donnell worked on “The West Wing” as a writer, consultant and executive producer.

Back in 2011, O’Donnell made comments to Adweek’s TVNewser that made it seem like he wouldn’t stick around for this long anyway.

“Screenwriting is my business; this thing was always a sideline. I can’t look up and imagine myself doing this [cable news] for three years,” he told TVNewser at the time.