‘X-Files’ Fans Like the Latest Episode, But Wonder ‘Did That Make Sense?’

The first one-off episode of the season might have been confusing, but it felt to fans more like old-school “X-Files”

Last Updated: January 10, 2018 @ 7:43 PM

(Note: This post contains spoilers for the premiere and Jan. 10 episodes of “The X-Files.”)

The premiere of “The X-Files” Season 11 had a lot of fans frustrated.

The first episode of the show’s second revival season pulled a number of twists that bothered a lot of people. Not only did it pull an “It was all a dream” retcon of the Season 10 finale, but it also apparently reworked the parentage of the son of Dana Scully (Gillian Anderson) and Fox Mulder (David Duchovny).

The suggestion that the show’s primary antagonist impregnated Scully with “alien science” without her knowledge had many fans taking to social media to voice their annoyance.

But fans seemed to receive the second episode of the season, dubbed “This,” with more enthusiasm. This episode was more akin to what fans enjoyed in the classic series back in the 1990s — it was mostly a one-off episode about a smaller-scale conspiracy, but it gave hints at the larger arc of the season. It also brought back (a version of) one of the show’s fan-favorite trio of geeks who frequently showed up to help Mulder, the Lone Gunmen.

While many fans seemed happy with the return to form of “The X-Files,” a few admitted that this one — which concerned a computer simulation where people’s minds were downloaded without their consent and forced to help the bad guys — didn’t make a ton of sense.

https://twitter.com/ArthurForward/status/951272977924059136

The episode ended with Mulder and Scully managing to destroy the simulation, only to discover that there were backups, and all their work hadn’t really saved anyone. But fans of the original series will remember that episodes with those downbeat, confusing endings were often par for the course. In fact, those elements might be why so many people liked this one.

At least all those evil server backups mean somebody listened to their company’s IT pro, though.