The actors have spoken, and the 2015 awards race is still a muddle.
Nominations for the 22nd annual Screen Actors Guild Awards did little to clarify a confusing awards picture on Wednesday morning, because members of the SAG nominating committee were sometimes predictable, sometimes surprising and often confounding.
Jennifer Lawrence didn’t get in for “Joy,” but Helen Mirren did for “Woman in Gold,” to go with the nomination she also got for her supporting role in “Trumbo.” Comic legend Lily Tomlin didn’t make it for her touching and funny role in “Grandma,” but comedian Sarah Silverman did for her dead-serious turn in “I Smile Back.”
“Steve Jobs,” “Carol,” “Room” and “The Danish Girl” landed two individual nominations each, but were shut of the key ensemble category, while “Straight Outta Compton” was nominated for its ensemble without a single individual nomination.
“Spotlight,” the presumed frontrunner for that ensemble award (and for the Best Picture Oscar), got an expected nomination in that category — but only one of its cast members received an individual nomination, and that was Rachel McAdams rather than Michael Keaton or Mark Ruffalo.
(One lesson: Supporting actor is a more crowded category this year than supporting actress.)
And the biggest film nominee was not “Spotlight” or “Steve Jobs” or “The Martian” or “Carol,” all of them expected to be major Oscar contenders, but Jay Roach‘s period Hollywood story “Trumbo,” which is an also-ran on most prognosticators’ lists but landed three separate SAG nominations.
So what does it mean? That actors like stories about Hollywood? Sure. That the members of the SAG nominating committee admired “Carol” and “Room” more than they loved them? Maybe.
It definitely means that screeners are the way to reach the SAG nom-com, and that it’s best not to leave things to the last minute. The three late-breaking awards contenders, Alejandro G. Inarritu’s “The Revenant,” David O.Russell’s “Joy” and Quentin Tarantino‘s “The Hateful Eight,” managed a single nomination between them, for Leonardo DiCaprio‘s unassailable performance in “The Revenant.”
All three directors have had films that won the SAG ensemble award in the past six years — Inarritu with “Birdman,” Russell with “American Hustle” and Tarantino with “Inglourious Basterds” — but none were even nominated in that category this time around, a clear sign that the 2,200 randomly selected actors who make up the nom-com are best reached not though high-profile last-minute screenings, but with screener DVDs.
“The Hateful Eight” didn’t send screeners; “The Revenant” did, at the last minute, but they were individually watermarked, which meant that they could only be sent to members who had previously signed a separate agreement. As many as 500 nom-com voters did not do so.
So in the end, the SAG nominations boosted the fortunes of “Trumbo,” “The Big Short,” “Beasts of No Nation,” “Straight Outta Compton,” Michael Shannon in “99 Homes” and Sarah Silverman, and added Helen Mirren in “Woman in Gold” to an awards-season radar on which it had rarely appeared.
And they essentially took a pass when it came to some of the biggest awards-season question marks of 2015, particularly among the December releases. If SAG voters didn’t help “The Revenant” and “Joy” and “The Hateful Eight,” they didn’t necessarily hurt them, either; those campaigns will depend on other, different voters down the road.
On the television side, most of the usual suspects showed up: Jon Hamm continued his awards-show farewell tour for “Mad Men,” Jeffrey Tambor and Claire Daines and Julianna Margulies and Jim Parsons will have the chance to win again.
The surprises were limited to Rami Malek crashing the drama-actor category for “Mr. Robot,” Ellie Kemper grabbing a comedy actress nod for “Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt” — and, perhaps, the final season of “Key & Peele” landing an ensemble nomination even though its ensemble consists of two guys, Keegan-Michael Key and Jordan Peele.
Despite being a major critical and box office success, Matt Damon failed to get a nomination for his performance as astronaut Mark Watney in "The Martian."
20th Century Fox
SURPRISE: Sarah Silverman
The comedian got serious for indie drama “I Smile Back,” and it appears to have paid off, because her peers are finally taking her seriously too. Lumped in with revered thespians including Cate Blanchett and Helen Mirren, her nomination for Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Leading Role marks the first time the actress has been recognized for a dramatic performance.
Broad Green Pictures
SNUB: Fox got 0 nominations
Fox was the only one of the Big 4 networks to receive no nominations this year. While NBC got only 2 and CBS and ABC got just 3, it is still surprising that no original Fox shows managed to make it onto the list.
Speaking of Fox, “Last Man on Earth” was one of the funniest new shows of 2015, and it also has one of the smallest casts. Considering the title, most of the responsibility falls on the shoulders of star Will Forte, who consistently succeeds in delivering big laughs. At least he's not only other crowd pleaser on Fox to have been ignored.
Fox
SNUB: “Empire” got 0 nominations
“Empire” is broadcast cable’s biggest series, thanks to its addictive storyline and strong cast of characters led by Taraji P. Henson’s Cookie Lyon and Terrence Howard’s Lucious Lyon. Henson already received a Primetime Emmy nom this year, so her absence in these SAG nominations is among the biggest head scratchers of them all.
Tom McCarthy’s ensemble drama about the Boston Globe investigation into the Catholic Church cover-up of dozens of local priest molestations is a favorite to take home the SAG Award for best cast, but if anyone deserved individual recognition, it was Ruffalo. The "Avengers" star used subtle mannerisms to completely disguise himself as real-life investigative reporter Mike Rezendes without relying on makeup, and delivered some of the most powerful moments in the film.
Open Road Films
SURPRISE: Netflix got the most TV nominations
In a sign of things to come, streaming service Netflix took home 8 nominations. That puts them ahead of every major broadcaster and cable powerhouses HBO and AMC. Netflix' offerings this year include season three of original series "Orange Is the New Black" and the original movie "Beasts of No Nation"
Netflix
SURPRISE: "Key & Peele" gets fond farewell
Comedy Central's "Key & Peele" got their first ever SAG nomination this year. The twist is that this is also the year the show ended, as exclusively reported by TheWrap
Comedy Central
SNUB: No individual nominations for "Straight Outta Compton"
Universal's NWA biopic did get the nomination for Best Ensemble Film Cast, but failed to garner any for the performances of breakout stars like O'Shea Jackson Jr., Aldis Hodge, Jason Mitchell, or even Paul Giamatti
Tatiana Maslany got a SAG nomination last year for her performance in BBC America's "Orphan Black," in addition to an Emmy nod and a Golden Globe nomination the year before. But this year, the Canadian actress got no love from the Guild
BBCA
SNUB: Will Smith
This blockbuster movie star hasn’t taken on a heavy dramatic role since 2008’s “Seven Pounds,” and he did it convincingly this year in NFL medical drama “Concussion” as the Nigerian-born doctor who took on one of the biggest sports institutions in America to raise awareness for the brain damage players risk with every tackle.
Village Roadshow Pictures
SURPRISE: Rami Malek
The actor who broke out of playing small supporting roles earlier this year by becoming USA Network’s “Mr. Robot” just scored his very first major acting nomination in the Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Drama Series, alongside awards season veterans Kevin Spacey, Bob Odenkirk, Jon Hamm and Peter Dinklage.
The 70-year-old actress received not one, but two nominations this year -- one for her leading role in “Woman in Gold,” and the other for a supporting role in “Trumbo” -- which is a rare accomplishment, especially surprising because "Woman in Gold" wasn't critically acclaimed and awards darling Jennifer Lawrence has a new drama in theaters this year, as well.
TWC
SURPRISE: Nicole Kidman
The actress received an Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Television Movie or Miniseries nomination for "Grace of Monaco," which is surprising because it only ended up on Lifetime after The Weinstein Company pulled it from theatrical release, and critics who saw it weren't very kind, either.
Lifetime
SURPRISE: Bill Murray
The actor was ignored by the Screen Actors Guild for a very memorable performance as a cranky old man last year in "St. Vincent," but it turns out, all he had to do was put on a Santa hat and play his delightful self in Netflix original holiday special "A Very Murray Christmas." Who knew it was that easy?
Netflix
SNUB: Oscar Isaac
Somebody show SAG voters a screener of HBO's "Show Me a Hero," from "Crash" director Paul Haggis and "The Wire" creator David Simon. While Bill Murray played himself to score a nomination in the category recognizing a Male Actor in a Television Movie or Miniseries, Isaac's charismatic portrayal of real-life Yonkers, NY Mayor Nick Wasicsko was ignored.
HBO
SNUB: "Brooklyn Nine-Nine" ensemble
You even watching this show, SAG members? Andy Samberg, Andre Braugher, Joe Lo Truglio, and Stephanie Beatriz could all be deserving of individual comedy nominations; together, they are a powerhouse. And that isn't even mentioning the excellent contributions of Terry Crews, Melissa Fumero and Chelsea Peretti.
Fox
1 of 17
While some get their first nominations, other actors and networks get left out entirely
Despite being a major critical and box office success, Matt Damon failed to get a nomination for his performance as astronaut Mark Watney in "The Martian."