‘Captain America: The Winter Soldier’ Success Signals 3D Rebound

'Captain America: The Winter Soldier' Success Signals 3D Rebound

The format is stabilizing, not shrinking

“Captain America: The Winter Soldier” galvanized the weekend box office with a $96 million debut.

Its record-breaking opening wasn't enough to bring 3D back to its “Avatar” and “Gravity”-level highs, but the results do point to a new normal for comic book and special effects films released in the format. Domestically, 3D continues to lack the sizzle it enjoys in foreign markets, where it can generate between 80 to 90 percent of a film's box office, but it would be a mistake to count it out.

Also read: ‘Captain America: Winter Soldier’ Storms to Record $96 Million at Box Office

3D showings of “Captain America: The Winter Soldier” were responsible for 23 percent of its stateside total. That seems anemic, until other premium formats that combine 3D with wider screens such as IMAX are taken into account. In that context, 3D comprised a solid 40 percent of “Captain America: The Winter Soldier's” box office — a figure that is roughly in line with “Man of Steel” (41 percent ) and “Thor: The Dark World” (39 percent), and substantially better than “Wolverine” (30 percent) and “World War Z” (34 percent).

“The 3D dollars will be well above expectations,” Eric Wold, an analyst with B. Riley & Co., said, predicting that companies such as RealD will get a nice boost in 3D licensing revenues.

Last summer, 3D appeared to be waning as a box office force, with event films such as “Turbo” and “Wolverine” reaching new lows with the format. However, Hollywood appears to be deploying 3D more effectively and the box office contribution of those rose-colored spectacles has stabilized.

Action films can reliably rack up between 30 percent to 50 percent of their opening grosses from 3D screenings, while animated films can generate between 20 percent to 30 percent of their initial earnings from the format. There are outliers such as “Gravity” and “Life of Pi,” that represent breakthroughs in 3D cinematography and drama and can be expected to derive as much as 70 percent of their ticket sales from those screenings.

Also read: 49 Summer Movies on Our Radar: From ‘Amazing Spider-Man’ to Tina Fey's Next Comedy (Photos)

“People who wrote off 3D got it wrong,” Wold said. “But it did get exhibitors to refocus on how they were using 3D, and to choose the right movies to use 3D on and to market them more effectively.”

“3D percentages have reached levels that suggest we're starting to get the rebound we've been waiting for,” Wold said.

Even if domestic audiences fail to have their passions rekindled, 3D is here to stay. After all, 3D screenings are still selling out in major markets such as China, where “Captain America: The Winter Soldier” scored the biggest opening in Marvel Studios history, so it's a safe bet that the next costumed vigilante will be saving the world in three dimensions.

  • moviedemon

    I knew when I saw the numbers for Winter Soldier, it was just a matter of time before I started seeing headlines like this one.

    I don't think there's so much a rebound of interest in 3D here in the US, but more accurately – the numbers confirm what most people already know – only about 2 in 10 films are worthy of the format.

  • RBrownfield

    The anemic totals may have something to do with 3D being so expensive, people are opting for the lower ticket prices. I don't know one person who chooses to see a movie in 3D. If they have seen it in 3D, it's either because that is the only option, or because the times available are the only ones they have time for. There are 3 to 4 times as many time slots used for 3D than for 2D in the local theaters.

    • Jesse Skeen

      Charging extra for 3D is pure greed. I would never see a 3D movie in 2D though, and hate when they do separate 2D showings since it lets those who have already made their minds up that they hate 3D avoid seeing a good 3D presentation, and I always have to make sure I'm going to the right showing. Same with when they had those separate “Fool Screen” DVD releases.

  • Stephen Hill

    This is what I have been saying all along. If you look at the numbers, we're not seeing a precipitous drop, but a normalisation of 3D numbers. 3D is here to stay, regardless of the doom and gloom predictions of the naysayers. Home 3D may have fared worse, but as technology improves, look for normalisation there as well.