Time Falls for Fake NYC Tornado Photo

Time Falls for Fake NYC Tornado Photo

Published: September 17, 2010 @ 7:25 am
Print this page
By Dylan Stableford

A brief storm that spawned a possible tornado swept through Brooklyn -- and Twitter -- on Thursday, causing at least one death and millions of dollars in Flickr-worthy damage.

It also caused Time magazine to briefly lose its reportorial mind.

A photo that supposedly showed the tornado as it was crossing the water near the Statue of Liberty, shortly before hitting the borough, began circulating on Twitter.

Time posted the photo -- nabbed from a Twitter user -- on its newsfeed blog (which purports to showcase "What's Vital and Viral on the Web, in Real Time") under the headline "Gotham Tornado: Amazing Photo of Twister Passing Statue of Liberty."

"It's a freak event, a tornado in the heart of New York City," Steven James Snyder wrote on Time's blog. "The image above may be once in a lifetime."

Snyder was right about that. The image was a real, once-in-a-lifetime photo. The problem is ... it was taken in 1976, apparently lifted from the NOAA website.

(For what it's worth, my gut reaction was to call "bull----" on the rapidly growing meme; not boasting here, as I've been known to drink the Twitter-mixed Kool Aid, too -- just proving that this wasn't a second-guess.)

Time eventually corrected the post: “Since this story first posted, it has come to our attention that the image shown above is from 1976."

It's a cautionary tale is blind faith, a rush to corral page views -- and proof that even a publication with deep resources like Time can be duped by the Twitterati.

Tags: fake, Media, NYC, Time, tornado
Sign Up For First Take

Get Our Daily Email, and Receive Invitations to Our Screenings Series

Start your day with all of the news worth knowing

What's First Take?

Description

Media Alley looks at the media landscape from print to digital, legacy media to new media. 

Subscribe to Media Alley
Most Popular
Columns
Wrap Tweets