Olympics: Is Julia Lipnitskaia's Routine ‘Schindler's List: On Ice'? Good

Olympics: Is Julia Lipnitskaia's Routine 'Schindler's List: On Ice'? Good

It's not hard to find parallels in a country that systematically oppresses gays

Russian skater Julia Lipnitskaia's gold-medal winning performance to John Williams’ theme from “Schindler's List” has been knocked in some circles as “Schindler's List: On Ice.”

But what would be wrong with that?

Also read: Sochi Olympics: Stray Dog, Ring Fail Bring Awkward to the Opening Ceremony (Photos)

Katarina Witt first started skating to the music in 1994 in homage to Steven Spielberg's film and in remembrance of the Holocaust. Since then, as Slate noted, skaters including Irina Slutskaya and Johnny Weir have also used Williams’ music. The 15-year-old Lipnitskaia, like Witt, dressed in red to recall the girl in red in Spielberg's film: a Polish Jewish girl whose death fills Oskar Schindler with remorse. Her dress provides the only flash of color in the film, and makes her death stand out from all the others, just as it did in Schindler's mind.

Spielberg praised Witt's performance, which was especially notable because Witt is German. Lipnitskaia's routine Sunday was choreographed, according to Slate, by Ilia Averbukh, a former Olympic ice dancing medalist who is a Russian Jew.

Also read: ‘Daily Show,’ ‘Colbert Report’ to Begin Sochi Spoofing Monday Night – ‘But No Gay Stuff’

It's easy to mock anything by adding the phrase “on ice,” because it recalls schlocky winter spectaculars that pack in kids to watch their favorite cartoon characters skate. The joke may go back to the 1989 comedy “What's Alan Watching,” which featured a fake ad for a show called “Gandhi on Ice.”

Lipnitskaia's skate was an easy target.

“Get Spielberg on the horn!” tweeted Digg creative and editorial director David Weiner on  Sunday. “Stevie baby, you seein’ this? Girl's a star! And not a yellow one! Say it with me: ‘Schindler's List: On Ice'!”

Okay, good one.

But seriously? We should remember the Holocaust any way we can: in museums and in documentaries, of course. But also in comic books, like “Maus.” Or even in bad movies, like “Monuments Men.” Or on ice. We should remember it in any format that keeps us from forgetting.

There's a dumb tendency in America to call everyone Nazis: people who correct your grammar, hand out parking tickets, or try to convince you to sign up for health care.

But what the Nazis actually did was systematically target certain groups, declare them beneath other humans, and take away more and more of their rights, including, eventually, their right to life.

We as a species haven't really nailed the concept of “never again.” Take for example Lipnitskaia's country, Russia, the host of the Winter Olympics. Russia has made it illegal for people to be gay. And before we get too sanctimonious, the U.S. has its share of anti-gay laws, too.

No one is suggesting that gay people are being treated as brutally as the Jews were during the Holocaust. But the Nazis had to start somewhere.

Trying to take away a little of someone's humanity doesn't by any stretch make you a Nazi. But it makes you a little more like one.

Lipnitskaia's routine is so powerful because she's closer in age to the Girl in Red that any of the skaters who have come before her: With her slight size and cherubic appearance, she painfully recollects the children who died. Children may not only look up to her, but see their own faces in hers.

This year we'll celebrate the soldiers who won World War II, with lots of cable and public television marking the anniversary of D-Day. And that's wonderful.

But I'm happier about the fact that for a few minutes Sunday, young kids all over the world watched one of their own recall the greatest horror of the last century. She did it artfully, in a way that acknowledged tragedy without crossing over to exploitation or traumatic imagery.

If you don't think anything artistic or meaningful can happen on ice, well, to each his own. But if we want history to survive, we need to pass it on in a way the next generation will understand. In as many ways as possible, to reach everyone we can.

Even on ice.

Watch the routine, as Lipnitskaia performed it at the European Figure Skating Championships:

  • cec

    Is that not what we have done to the unborn these last 41 years? Dehumanize them and take away their right to life? If we do uphold the rights of all, how can we uphold the rights of gays or any other group? The trouble with this thinking is that one day it could be me or you.

  • barbarajoanne

    Thank you for this.

  • KathyNYC

    I AGREE it was a moving performance to beautiful music..by an American composer. David and White are skating to Russian music, the Russian girl is skating to USA”s John Williams, and her routine is choreographed by a Russian Jew. Schindler's List is all about the horrors of persecution and it's being honored by a young girl in a red dress. Yes Russia has anti-gay laws. I am American and I love my country but I don't agree with everything it says and legislates. Should I not show what I believe to be important? Is Yulia not allowed the same? Isn't this what the Olympics SHOULD be about?

    • maureengrooms

      I love this little girl!