Home / Movies / ‘Superman Returns’ Director Bryan Singer on Why He Cast Brandon Routh Over Henry Cavill

‘Superman Returns’ Director Bryan Singer on Why He Cast Brandon Routh Over Henry Cavill

'Superman Returns' Director Bryan Singer on Why He Cast Brandon Routh Over Henry Cavill

The “X-Men” filmmaker also offered his thoughts on Zack Snyder's “Man of Steel”

“Superman Returns” director Bryan Singer offered his thoughts on Zack Snyder's “Man of Steel” in a recent interview with Empire (via Comic Book Movie).

“I am in awe of the world building and the scope of that picture. It's tough for me. I'm not a critic and it starts to get into a weird thing where one director is talking about another director. I know how hard it is to make a movie, especially one of these movies and especially a Superman movie, and there was so much I was impressed with in that movie,” said Singer, who offered a minor criticism as well.

Also Read: Bryan Singer Unveils ‘X-Men: Days of Future Past’ Sentinel in All its Giant Glory (Photo)

“There were things I might have done a little differently just because of the way I view the character. Don't misinterpret that as me not liking something,” cautioned Singer, who added that his thoughts shouldn't be mistaken as a proper review.

While Singer praised Henry Cavill‘s performance, he said there was a distinct reason why Brandon Routh was cast in “Superman Returns” over Cavill.

Also Read: Bryan Singer Tweets Beastly Photo of ‘X-Men’ Star Nicholas Hoult

“Um… I think Henry Cavill is great. I knew Henry. He and I were friends years ago. Oddly enough, the reason I didn't cast him was because I was making a sequel to Christopher Reeve and I wanted somebody who embodied Reeve more.”

Check out Empire's 25 different covers for Singer's upcoming movie “X-Men: Days of Future Past” by clicking this link.

  • Matt Clayton

    I would've liked to see how Singer would've handled “Man of Steel” (with the Snyder cast) with his own creative team.

    In hindsight, I'm glad Singer didn't go with Cavill… but I feel bad for Brandon Routh. He's not doing much right now.

  • Mightym-o-u-s-e

    I loved both films, I hold them dear 2 my heart. . .Jason Lane and his Aquaman pajamas and Man of Steel filled my eyes with tears, sob. . .

  • kirby76

    I thought Brandon Routh did a great, witty job of suggesting Christopher Reeve's interpretation without doing a corny impersonation. He was the only really good thing about that film, which borrowed ideas from the first one that were already cheesy in '78, and I couldn't tell if it was sendup or tribute.
    Routh is handsome, charming and talented, yet he languishes while Zac Efron is kept busy as a beaver. But I don't want to dwell on THAT for too long.

    • Rick

      Really? Brandon Routh over Henry Cavill? What a disappointment. I have seen Superman with Christopher Reeve and not looking forward to a repeat. Henry Cavill looks more like the comic book hero Superman that I remember.

      • topi

        I think that's what he was trying to explain. I kinda see it as a trilogy. he left and now hes back. totally different to mos. mos is based on the comic. and superman returns is based on the Christopher reeves movies.

        • Kayla Rose Zampino

          Thats how I see it as well, I think Brandon did a great job :)

  • Jason

    Bryan Singer's movie is not even in the same ballpark as the new one. Thank God for Zack Snyder's movie.

  • TV101

    Ah – Brian I think we all know why Brandon Routh was cast. And I think the reasons go beyond what is being said in this article. That being said you were asked to do what you were asked to do – TRUE casting wise but – it was a total miss.

  • Adam Contreras

    Both this movie directors are clowns. I did like 300 & Sucker Punch from Zach Snyder but Watchmen was too brutal & disturbing for me to see. On Bryan Singer in the other hand, I like Glorious Bastards from Tarantino more then Valkrie since about 95% of all cast where speaking British accent with German uniforms. This being said that's why I call this 2 movie directors clowns. Oh yes I almost forgot, X-Men 3 & Superman Return wasn't good. If only Zack hired Christopher Nolan AGAIN, Christian Bale would still be Batman & Bruce Wayne today.

  • Benjamin Roussey

    Routh was outstanding but the action was lacking in that movie. Man of Steel blew that out of the water.

    • Kayla Rose Zampino

      MOS had TOO much action, Superman Returns didnt have enough.. We need a common ground. But overall, they were both great and both actors played Superman amazingly.

      • Benjamin Roussey

        Too much action? Did not know where was such a thing. There was plenty of outstanding dialogue in MOS. Yes, Routh did a job but that little petite Lois Lane was not right and the red headed Adams is not right either. Terrible casting – Amy Adams. No way. Everyone was solid though, not her. Russel Crowe, Costner – spectacular – his mother and so on.

  • Benjamin Roussey

    Apparently the American woman would rather have the right to
    kill their child (rather than giving it up for adoption) than get a job. Well,
    since many American woman are childless and poor, that is what they get.

  • Benjamin Roussey

    The debt was $10.626 trillion on the day Mr. Obama took office. The latest
    calculation from Treasury shows the debt has now hit $17.4 trillion.

    It's the most rapid increase in the debt under any U.S. president.

    The national debt increased $4.9 trillion during the eight-year presidency of
    George W. Bush. The debt now is rising at a pace to surpass that amount during
    Mr. Obama's four-year term.

  • Benjamin Roussey

    – WTC Bombing – 50,000 people would have died because of no escape from the
    stairwell (18 people actually died) ; 2 African embassy bombings around 96/97 –
    many people died, mainly Africans ; USS Cole attack in 2000 – Clinton did
    nothing about any of this accept fire tomahawks from 800 miles out (that is all
    he would ever do) – several sailors dead. Al Queda was emboldened because of
    Clinton’s weak responses – this led to 9-11 and Bush hammered them unlike Al
    Gore would have ever done.