Director Rupert Goold’s “Judy,” which had its premiere at the Telluride Film Festival on Friday as part of a tribute to Renee Zellweger, contains what is easily the best performance of Zellweger’s career. The film itself works best as a showcase for the actress’ extraordinary turn, as she transforms herself into Judy Garland, focusing on the last performances of the singing legend’s career in the months leading up to her tragic death at the age of 47.
Zellweger has always been good — probably better than many of the roles she’s been given, especially the ones early in her career. In “Judy,” she gets to the core of Garland with a raw intensity of a woman in a spiral. Zellweger’s Judy seems to move through the film in a kind of trance, due in large part to the drugs and the booze, but also as someone who was chewed up and spit out by the Hollywood machine since her adolescence.
It has always been one of the saddest of Hollywood horror stories that Judy Garland was both Dorothy in the “The Wizard of Oz” and the kid to whom MGM was feeding speed and downers to keep her thin and working non-stop. She never had any kind of childhood or normal life to speak of. Some can survive it, others can’t. The sensitive ones like Garland are destroyed by it.
The film “Judy” takes us along for one last bumpy ride. It’s 1969, Judy’s money has run out, her third husband has taken custody of her two kids, and she’s invited to London for a series of performances at the Talk of the Town nightclub. Some of these performances can be seen on YouTube, and clearly Zellweger has been studying them very closely: It is sometimes impossible to tell the difference between the two.
On her way to marrying her fifth husband, the film watches as Judy falls apart. Even if those around her can occasionally get her on stage to sing, she often fails and walks off, as Garland did in real life. Zellweger’s Judy struggles with insomnia, tossing and turning. We flash back to Judy’s early days at MGM, where she repeatedly tried to escape a life of being a studio pony. The only thing Judy could hold onto was the love she received from her audience when she performed.
Zellweger captures Garland’s frail and slightly twitchy body, her voice, her look and mannerisms. Things as subtle as how Garland pronounces the word “wonderful” are not missed by the exacting Zellweger, who has brought the legend to vivid, full-color life. Even if she can’t quite match the beauty of that famous voice, Zellweger captures the spirit of how Garland sang.
Goold keeps the camera trained on Zellweger for nearly every frame of the movie, pulling very close to show how the dark red lipstick bleeds into the lines around her lips, or how badly her eyeliner has been painted on. Zellweger’s face turned out to be a perfect canvas to manifest Garland’s face. The “Chicago” star faced the same kind of cruelty recently in the form of comments aimed at how she was aging. We expect too much from our stars — we forget they are only human.
“Judy” isn’t a film that has much else going for it except that performance, though there is significant mention of Garland’s legacy with the LGBT community when Judy befriends a gay couple who wait outside the theater to meet her. The film is written by Tom Edge and based on the Peter Quilter’s 2005 play “End of the Rainbow,” which came to Broadway in 2012.
Zellweger likely lands in the Oscar race with this performance. It is not just the best thing she’s ever done but a tender, memorable realization of a star who once shined very brightly but whose light was never built to last.
11 Highest-Grossing Music Biopics, From Tupac's 'All Eyez on Me' to Elton John's 'Rocketman' (Photos)
A look back at Hollywood's most successful musical biopics, whose subjects range from Tupac to Ritchie Valens to Elton John. (All box office totals are for domestic ticket sales.)
11. "All Eyez On Me" (2017) $44.9 million Critics were not impressed by Benny Boom's biopic on the life and career of Tupac Shakur, but fans of the late rapper showed up en masse on its opening weekend to help the film beat box-office expectations and earn nearly $45 million at the box office.
Lionsgate/Summit
10. "Jersey Boys" (2014) $47 million Clint Eastwood is known for directing grittier films like "The 15:17 to Paris" and "The Mule," but he also contributed to musical history with a 2014 jukebox drama about Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons, which earned $47 million domestically and $67 million worldwide.
Warner Bros.
9. "Amadeus" (1984) $51.9 million Thirty-five years after its release, the Best Picture Oscar-winning adaptation of Peter Shaffer's play is still charming fans of Mozart ... and infuriating classical music scholars who insist that Antonio Salieri did not poison him.
Orion Pictures
8. "La Bamba" (1987) $54.2 million Ritchie Valens, writer of "La Bamba" and Pacoima's cherished native son, became known as much for his tragic death in a plane crash at the age of 17 as he was for his music. "La Bamba," starring Lou Diamond Phillips as the iconic rock star, goes deep into the family behind the guitar player, and how teenage fame forced Valens to make tough decisions.
Columbia Pictures
7. "Coal Miner's Daughter" (1980) $67 million In 1976, country star Loretta Lynn released a bestselling memoir, and plans were quickly set in motion to turn it into a biopic. "Coal Miner's Daughter" became both a Best Picture Oscar nominee and one of the top-grossing films of 1980. Sissy Spacek, who was personally picked by Lynn to play her, won the Best Actress Oscar.
Universal
6. "Ray" (2004) $75.3 million Speaking of Oscar winners, Jamie Foxx earned his Oscar 15 years ago for his depiction of Ray Charles in this biopic that also starred future Oscar winner Regina King. Charles' death four months before the film's release raised the biopic's profile, and Foxx honored Charles' memory during his Oscar acceptance speech.
Universal
5. "I Can Only Imagine" (2018) $83 million One of the biggest surprises of the 2018 box office was this film about Christian songwriter Bart Millard, who wrote the hit MercyMe song "I Can Only Imagine" in honor of his father. The film was such a hit that directors Andrew and Joe Erwin launched a new Christian film studio, Kingdom Studios, which has a first-look deal with Lionsgate.
Roadside Attractions
4. "Rocketman" (2019)$96.4 million As executive producer on a biopic fantasy musical about his life, Elton John demanded that "Rocketman" be an R-rated film because he "didn't lead a PG-13 life." Taron Egerton's performance blew away critics, as the film became a popular alternative to big summer sequels.
Paramount
3. "Walk The Line" (2005) $119.5 million Joaquin Phoenix earned an Oscar nomination for his performance as the legendary Johnny Cash, while Reese Witherspoon won Best Actress for her turn as Cash's wife, June. For 10 years, "Walk The Line" stood as the highest-grossing music biopic ever, until it was dethroned by...
Fox
2. "Straight Outta Compton" (2015) $161.2 million Made with the approval of Ice Cube and Dr. Dre and starring Cube's son, O'Shea, "Straight Outta Compton" pushed the biopic genre deeper into the realm of hip-hop with a retelling of N.W.A..'s career that gained an extra level of topicality with the rise of the Black Lives Matter movement. The film also elevated the career of director F. Gary Gray, who would go on to direct installments in the "Fast & Furious" and "Men in Black" franchises.
Universal
1. "Bohemian Rhapsody" (2018) $216.7 million There may be another music biopic in the future that passes "BoRhap"'s domestic total, but its worldwide total looks like it will stay atop the charts for a long time. With $903 million grossed globally and a Best Actor Oscar for lead star Rami Malek, it will likely enjoy a legacy as the most well-recognized music biopic ever made.
20th Century Fox
1 of 12
Far and away, ”Bohemian Rhapsody“ is king
A look back at Hollywood's most successful musical biopics, whose subjects range from Tupac to Ritchie Valens to Elton John. (All box office totals are for domestic ticket sales.)