Roman Polanski Denied Reinstatement to Film Academy by Judge

“Chinatown” director had sued the Oscars organization in April 2019

Last Updated: August 25, 2020 @ 1:23 PM

Roman Polanski’s move to be reinstated as a member of the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences has been denied by a Los Angeles judge, who ruled that the Oscars organization had a right to expel the director, a convicted child rapist.

Polanski was expelled from AMPAS in 2018 and the “Chinatown” director sued AMPAS in April 2019, claiming that he was expelled from the Academy without warning or due process.

Polanski was arrested and charged with raping a 13-year-old girl in 1977. After being imprisoned for 42 days and pleading guilty in a deal for time served and probation, Polanski learned that a judge was planning to go back on the plea deal. The director then fled the country to his native France before the sentencing, and he has remained a fugitive since then, with extradition efforts unsuccessful.

Polanski’s attorney, Harland Braun, did not immediately respond to TheWrap for a request for comment.

Judge Mary Strobel wrote in her argument that the Academy could have given Polanski advanced notice of their vote to expel him, however, the court disagreed that Polanski’s expulsion was “biased and unfair.” Strobel explained that Polanski was given reasons for his expulsion shortly after the vote was made, he was given an opportunity to plead his case and submit evidence for why he should remain, and he was given a fair hearing.

“While the Board could have found the circumstances surrounding Petitioner’s continued fugitive status, including his allegations of serious judicial and prosecutorial misconduct, mitigated the need for expulsion, the Board’s decision is supported by the evidence, was not arbitrary or capricious, and was not an abuse of discretion,” the judge wrote.

Polanski last year tried to get the case moved from what he called a “dishonest” Los Angeles Superior Court, saying he didn’t believe he would get fair treatment due to his past litigation. Around that time, The Academy previously defended its decision to expel Polanski (along with Bill Cosby) as “appropriate.”

Polanski was expelled 15 years after his film “The Pianist” took home Oscars for Best Director, Best Adapted Screenplay and Best Actor at the 75th Academy Awards. The film was nominated for Best Picture, but lost to “Chicago.”

Pamela Chelin contributed to this report.