RuPaul, the Emmy-winning host of the VH1 reality show “RuPaul’s Drag Race,” was forced to apologize for his statements about transgender drag performers this week, an apparent reversal of his long-held belief that drag and the trans community don’t mix.
The legendary drag performer caused an uproar when he told the Guardian that he would “probably not” allow trans women to compete on “Drag Race,” because the act of transitioning “changes the whole concept of what we’re doing [as drag queens].”
“Drag loses its sense of danger and its sense of irony once it’s not men doing it, because at its core it’s a social statement and a big F-you to male-dominated culture,” he said. “So for men to do it, it’s really punk rock, because it’s a real rejection of masculinity.”
The comments were met with criticism from fans, trans advocates andformer“Drag Race”contestants alike, but RuPaul doubled down. “You can take performance enhancing drugs and still be an athlete, just not in the Olympics,” he wrote in a much-derided tweet on Monday.
Many of RuPaul’s critics were quick to note that the history of drag culture is inextricably tied to the trans community — even “RuPaul’s Drag Race” itself has openly celebratedtrans women in the past.
“My drag was born in a community full of trans women, trans men, and gender non-conforming folks doing drag. That’s the real world of drag, like it or not. I thinks it’s fabulous and I will fight my entire life to protect and uplift it,” wrote Sasha Velour, the reigning “RuPaul’s Drag Race” champion who bested trans performer Peppermint in the Season 9 finale.
Following the backlash, RuPaul issued an apology for the statements on Twitter. The host and executive producer promised that the only factors at play in the casting process are “charisma, uniqueness, nerve and talent” — the show’s tongue-in-cheek criteria for success.
“Each morning I pray to set aside everything I THINK I know, so I may have an open mind and a new experience. I understand and regret the hurt I have caused. The trans community are heroes of our shared LGBTQ movement. You are my teachers,” he wrote.
RuPaul’s apology tweet was accompanied by an image of a flag with green and yellow stripes, the relevance of which was initially unclear.
However, some knowledgable Twitter users identified the image as a 1953 painting by minimalist artist Ellsworth Kelly titled “Train Landscape” — which naturally some to believe RuPaul attempted to search Google for the transgender pride flag (which features blue, pink and white stripes), accidentally typed in “trains” instead of “trans,” and posted the first result without realizing he had the wrong image.
This is not the first time RuPaul has made potentially exclusionary statements about drag’s relationship to the trans community.
Back in 2014 the host appeared on Marc Maron’s “WTF” podcast to defend his use of the derogatory term “tranny,” saying, “I can call myself a nigger, faggot, tranny all I want to, because I’ve fucking earned the right to do it. I’ve lived the life. I’ve been on the front line.”
And in a 2016 interview with Vulture, RuPaul said trans people and drag performers are “complete opposites.”
“We mock identity. They take identity very seriously. So it’s the complete opposite ends of the scale. To a layperson, it seems very similar, but it’s really not,” he said, brushing off the conversation as a “boring topic.”
So Monday’s concession and apology are a significant break from what RuPaul has said in the past, representing an apparent shift in his belief’s about the role of gender in drag performance. Whether that will play a role in the casting of “Drag Race” going forward, however, remains to be seen.
9 'RuPaul's Drag Race' Season 9 Moments, Ranked From Worst to Best (Videos)
Liza Minelli
It's shocking that a drag queen hadn't attempted Liza before the Season 9 "Snatch Game." Other gay icons have gotten the impersonation treatment multiple times -- Cher and Lady Gaga for starters -- but Liza? No takers? We're glad the first try was done by Alexis Michelle, who clearly reveres the superstar. Her theater training didn't always shine throughout the season, but it didn't get any more clear than this.
Eureka's elimination
"Drag Race" is full of atypical eliminations -- from two queens getting booted at once to Willam getting disqualified in Season 4. However, Eureka's elimination due to her torn ACL was the first time one had been eliminated for medical reasons, and it was bittersweet. Eureka later said that she received support from her fellow contestants and from the crew, which added to the emotional moment. That, plus the fact she got asked back for Season 10, makes us want to tune in.
Sarge
RuPaul loves Sarge. The contestants love Sarge. We love Sarge. The makeover challenge this season went behind the camera and allowed the queens to transform the crew into their drag daughters. They were all surprisingly charming, but one stood out. Sarge was quick-witted and hilarious, but when RuPaul asked him about working on the show and how he views drag, he was able to tone it down for a sweet moment where he showcased his respect for the medium.
Club Kids
It was by far the best runway of the season. The episode gave us a primer on Club Kid culture and allowed the contestants to stretch their creative muscles. Trinity, who had never experienced the culture before, was able to wow with her interpretation but it was Peppermint in her candy-inspired clown outfit that made our jaws drop.
Sasha Velour's entrance
There are only a handful of memorable workroom entrances, and this season, it belonged to Sasha Velour, who walked into the workroom, lifted her hands in the air, and screamed. We know now that Sasha is an intelligent, quirky queen with a unique sense of style, but in that moment we just felt her emotions. When you enter a new situation for the first time, you'd want to scream too (watch the first 20 seconds of the clip to the left).
Valentina compares herself to Selena
We're happy to see the return of a full-length reunion episode, since the queens are allowed to be more emotional and raw when they're not in front of a large audience. The whole episode was tense, but when the spotlight finally focused on Valentina and her fans, things got a little weird. When asked to explain her rabid fanbase -- some of which sent abusive messages to the other contestants -- she compared herself to 1990s superstar Selena. The other queens' faces are priceless.
"Macho Man"
In a season full of lackluster lip syncs, we were happy whenever Peppermint ended up in the bottom two. At least you knew she was going to put on a show. The one quality lip sync featured her and Alexis Michelle going head-to-head while lip syncing to "Macho Man." It's everything a lip sync should be -- competitive and dynamic. Alexis started it off with a mustache reveal, but once Peppermint pulled off her wig to reveal another wig, it was over.
"You look like Linda Evangelista"
We'll be saying this on our deathbeds. When Aja came for Valentina in "Untucked," she, in her own words, "aggressively complimented" her for what she felt was an undeserved spot in the Top 2. "You're perfect, you're beautiful, you look like Linda Evangelista, you're a model. Did you stone those tights? Oh you're smiling!" It's almost like Aja knew it was going to be on a T-shirt, or a song, which you can listen to at the clip.
Valentina shocker
This was the season of one-sided lip syncs. We thought it couldn't get worse than Charlie Hides sway and clap effort, but somehow it did. Valentina was doing well throughout the entire season, but a major misstep sent her into the bottom two and into a lip sync against Nina Bonina Brown. She could've gone all the way, as Ru said after, but when you don't know the words and refuse to take off your mask, you're going to be remembered for all the wrong reasons.
1 of 9
What this season lacked in pizzazz it made up for with shocking eliminations and quotable drama
Liza Minelli
It's shocking that a drag queen hadn't attempted Liza before the Season 9 "Snatch Game." Other gay icons have gotten the impersonation treatment multiple times -- Cher and Lady Gaga for starters -- but Liza? No takers? We're glad the first try was done by Alexis Michelle, who clearly reveres the superstar. Her theater training didn't always shine throughout the season, but it didn't get any more clear than this.