The Anti-Trump Convention Takes Hold With Kooks, BuzzFeed and Prophets of Rage
On Cleveland’s Public Square, a woman with massive pink fairy wings holds a sign: “Let Democracy Fly – Dump Trump!”
Sharon Waxman | July 21, 2016 @ 12:15 PM
Last Updated: July 21, 2016 @ 1:06 PM
As the Donald Trump coronation goes into its final stages at Cleveland’s Quicken Loans arena on Thursday, another convention is in full swing — the anti-Trump celebration that spills out of the meeting area at Public Square a block from the official goings-on.
That gathering is an assortment of artists, kooks, poets and true believers who make the otherwise monochromatic event a lot more interesting with music, shouting and pitched arguing.
The gathering includes one young woman with massive pink fairy wings and a sign reading, “Let Democracy Fly – Dump Trump!”
Another person has set up a checkerboard of square black signs with messages like: “Resist Racism. This country is broken. Racism is Violence.” And then merely: “DREAD.”
Despite fears in advance of the convention, the protest area in the square has not been a magnet for violence of any sort in this uncontested convention of an unconventional candidate.
Instead, the area has become a showcase for democracy at work, with pitched political debates punctuating the colorful signage and entertaining stunts.
An actress-ventriloquist named April has a furry Donald J. Tramp doll and does her shtick for any journalist who walks by and asks. She gives an opinion about the election, and then the doll weighs in: “I LOOOOOOVE Melania!!” he croaks.
Code Pink is among those gathered, as is a collection of anarchists. Cleveland police, their numbers increased by volunteers from more than 20 states, have made a few arrests this week — including of this Code Pink protester who burned an American flag.
Still, with the panic in the air ahead of the convention, the expected violence has not materialized. But debate has.
“I don’t call myself a white supremacist,” one heavyset man with a shaved head, blond beard and Trump t-shirt said in a spirited conversation on Tuesday with a group of anti-Trumpians.
“But do you agree with their ethics or whatever?” asked boy who looked to be about 13 and wore a Jewish yarmulke while holding an anti-Trump sign.
“You’re just using a slur to shut down discussion,” the blond guy replied.
Another demonstrator chimed in: “I’m not with these guys. My question is, What is your stance on the Muslim ban to the U.S.?”
Pro-Trump guy: “As Trump has stated it, I think it’s a pretty good idea.”
Anti-Trump guy: “Trump has not given any specifics on anything…”
Pro: “He said it’s a temporary ban on immigration from Muslim countries….”
Up at the Agora Theater, two miles east of the convention, a concert took place Wednesday night to protest against Trump, racism and probably police violence.
About 1,000 young men — hardly any women — in black t-shirts and piercings gathered to hear Prophets Against the Machine, a supergroup hip-hop band comprised of stars from the 1990s whose message has always been about challenging power.
A reporter was advised to remove her credentials to the convention, in the interest of safety.
The band’s lead members are Chuck D from Public Enemy, B-Real from Cypress Hill, and Rage Against the Machine members Tom Morello and others. They are definitely anti-Trump, though as the crowd throbs as a single pulsing mass to their bass it is pretty hard to make out any lyrics.
B Real Prophets Against the Machine, photo courtesy of Eric Greenspan
Still, the playlist looks like its own counter-establishment message:
Guerilla
Take the Power Back
Can’t Trust It
Bring the Noise
Bullet in the Head
Shut Em Down
Know Your Enemy
No Sleep/ Fight Power
*****
Back in more sober surroundings, BuzzFeed editor Ben Smith hosted a “Red, White and Blacklisted” party in the balmy evening air of the rooftop of one of Cleveland’s elegant 19th-century banks-turned-hotels. The crowd was a couple of hundred twentysomethings from the political set, happy for a free drink, a socializing opportunity and a break from the intensity of the convention hall.
The “Denied” theme is a clever celebration of Trump’s banning of media outlets from BuzzFeed to the Washington Post after negative coverage. The Daily Beast, Des Moines Register and The Huffington Post are among other outlets who’ve been banned by Trump. It’s a small club and a badge of honor for them.
“We were the first outlet to be banned from Trump’s events because one of our reporters did a profile of him in 2014 that he was unhappy about,” said Smith, leaning against the railing of the rooftop.
The profile, said Smith, “said he was a thin-skinned, second-rate figure surrounded by yes men who was not ever going to run.”
On Sunday, BuzzFeed published a 10,000-word piece by McKay Coppins, which Smith called a “mea culpa for having goaded Trump into running.”
BuzzFeed is admitted to the convention, since the Trump campaign doesn’t control press access — and Smith himself was pleased at the turnout to his Cleveland event.
“It’s the cool party for Republicans to be at,” said Smith, turning to greet Rand Paul’s former spokesman.
Trump Fans, Politicians and Protesters Behind the Scenes at Republican National Convention (Exclusive Photos)
Acclaimed photographer Edward Keating offers inside look at the events in Cleveland during the Republican National Convention
Trump cutout and Cleveland police.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Ivanka Trump escorts her father onto the stage to deliver his acceptance speech.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Trump supporters, restaurant window, Cleveland.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Donald Trump minutes after Ted Cruz's convention speech in which the Texas senator failed to endorse the GOP nominee.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Former New York City mayor Rudy Giuliani arrives on the convention floor before speaking to the crowd.
Photographed by Edward Keating.
Ivanka Trump introduces her father at RNC on Thursday night.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
An unidentified Code Pink activist is taken into custody after setting fire to an American flag during a protest on Wednesday.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Flag burned during protest outside the Republican National Convention on Wednesday.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Donald Trump delivers his acceptance speech Thursday night at the RNC.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
A woman carries a Donald Trump hand fan on the convention floor.
Photographed by Edward Keating.
Edward Keating
Sen. Jeff Sessions, one of the first people to support Donald Trump, on the floor at the RNC.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Hanif Phelps, protester, outside the RNC Wednesday.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Conservative radio and TV host Sean Hannity on Monday, first night of the convention at Quicken Loans Arena, Cleveland.
Photographed by Edward Keating.
Edward Keating
Republican National Convention delegates on Wednesday.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Melania Trump addresses convention on Monday, the first night, at Cleveland's Quicken Loans Arena.
Photographed by Edward Keating.
Edward Keating
Senator Jeff Sessions and Donald Trump's VP selection, Indiana Gov. Mike Pence, greet each other on Monday night at Quicken Loans Arena.
Photographed by Edward Keating.
Edward Keating
A woman from the anti-war group Code Pink appears in the protest zone outside the convention hall in Cleveland.
Photographed by Edward Keating.
Edward Keating
New Jersey Governor Chris Christie listens to speaker at Quicken Loans Arena on Monday night.
Photographed by Edward Keating.
Edward Keating
A preacher/protester calls on sinners to repent outside the convention in Cleveland.
Photographed by Edward Keating.
Edward Keating
A store window posts political posters in Cleveland during the convention.
Photographed by Edward Keating.
Edward Keating
People protest the Westboro Baptist Church outside the convention hall in Cleveland.
Photographed by Edward Keating.
Edward Keating
Delegates chant, "Send her to jail" Tuesday night at the Republican National Convention.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Cleveland police officers observe a protest outside the Quicken Loans Arena.
Photographed by Edward Keating.
Edward Keating
John Lynch, member of RNC's platform committee from Illinois.
Photographed by Edward Keating.
Edward Keating.
A Texas delegate Tuesday night at RNC.
Photographed by Edward Keating.
Edward Keating
New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie speaks Tuesday night at RNC.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Members of West Virginia delegation at the Quicken Loans Arena Tuesday night.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
An anti-Trump protester in Cleveland.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Protest with signs on ground by members of "We Will Not Be Silent."
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Nixon operative Roger Stone works his way through crowded streets of Cleveland on Wednesday.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Grant Wishard (left), a Republican from Washington, D.C., says he's thinking of voting for Hillary Clinton. Josh Delk (right), a conservative from Philadelphia, says he's dissatisfied with both major candidates and will not vote this year: "I'm going to sit this one out."
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
A police officer photographs protesters outside the convention.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Mounted police on loan from Fort Worth, Texas, stand guard at Public Square. Police from 20-plus states have provided additional security for the RNC.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Local residents sell Trump merchandise on the streets of Cleveland.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
A lone protester on the street.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Protesters carrying biblical signs shout slogans about how they believe African Americans don't want to work and get more abortions than "any other color of people."
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
NBC's "Meet the Press" moderator Chuck Todd (right), talks on Wednesday with Utah Sen. Mike Lee, who continues to refrain from supporting Donald Trump.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Delegates at the RNC Wednesday night.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
Workers clean up at Quicken Loans Arena at end of convention Thursday night.
Photographed by Edward Keating
Edward Keating
1 of 40
Acclaimed photographer Edward Keating offers inside look at the events in Cleveland
Acclaimed photographer Edward Keating offers inside look at the events in Cleveland during the Republican National Convention