‘The Peanuts Movie’ Review: Charlie Brown Survives the Leap to 3D
Designed more for kids who know the characters from TV specials rather than the comic strip, this cartoon tempers its boisterousness with a hint of melancholy
PEANUTS PUB STILL B02_WB_: Charlie Brown, Snoopy and the Peanuts gang (Franklin, Lucy, Linus, Peppermint Patty and Sally) revel in a snow day.
Photo credit: Twentieth Century Fox & Peanuts Worldwide LLC
It’s been 15 years or so since the demise of the landmark newspaper comic strip “Peanuts” and the death of its legendary creator, Charles M. Schulz, which means that “The Peanuts Movie” will be playing to at least one generation who knows Charlie Brown, Linus, Lucy and all the rest only as characters from holiday TV specials.
“Peanuts” on the page had an adult sensibility that children could also enjoy, but the animated versions have always been aimed at kids, with enough subtlety and intelligence that grown-ups could also be entertained.
“The Peanuts Movie” maintains this tradition; it’s a kid movie through and through, but care has been taken not to disrupt the gentle timelessness of the TV cartoons. (The original strips, if you go back and read them, never shied away from topical references.)
Schroeder doesn’t play Beethoven in Garage Band, no one has a cellphone, Snoopy still composes his purple prose on a manual typewriter, and the children still fill their days with ice skating and baseball. (Sure, Meghan Trainor and Flo Rida are on the soundtrack, but so is Vince Guaraldi.)
And since every 3D cartoon seemingly must include a flying sequence, Snoopy and Woodstock are there to oblige with some lengthy fantasies about a doghouse-mounted beagle facing off against the Red Baron over the French countryside. To the film’s credit, these moments are integrated into the story more successfully than the tacked-on WWI subplot in “It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown.”
Snoopy’s fantasies involve an unattainable love, which ties in perfectly with the main plot here: the sudden arrival of the Little Red-Haired Girl (voiced by Francesca Capaldi) and the flutter she brings to the clumsy, insecure and generally already-flummoxed Charlie Brown (Noah Schnapp). But the plot, such as it is, mainly exists as a framework for beloved “Peanuts” tropes like Charlie Brown’s five-cent visits to would-be psychiatrist Lucy (Hadley Belle Miller) or Linus (Alexander Garfin) and his constant defense of his security blanket.
Director Steve Martino (“Ice Age: Continental Drift,” “Horton Hears a Who!”), in keeping with contemporary trends in animation, has rendered these characters in computer-generated three dimensions. While Schulz himself might not have approved — whenever you read about why he appreciated director Bill Melendez’s work on the “Peanuts” TV specials and theatrical features, the adjective “flat” is often cited — the film’s version of this world goes down pretty easily.
Did we need to see the individual strands of Frieda’s naturally curly hair or the fuzz on Snoopy’s face? Not really. Do those visual characteristics stop calling attention to themselves after a few minutes? For me, yes.
The screenplay by Bryan Schulz, Craig Schulz and Cornelius Uliano keeps the jokes coming at a steady pace — some of them will be familiar to fans, but they’ve also struck out into some new territory, from a great running gag about an out-of-control model plane to a playful self-referential joke about merchandising.
“Peanuts” purists looking to be rankled will no doubt find plenty to cause alarm. There’s the CG animation, and the fact that we see and hear so much of the mysterious Red-Haired Girl (always off-panel in the strips, though she did make some TV appearances), and a scene in which Peppermint Patty (Venus Schultheis) acknowledges that Snoopy is indeed a dog and not just a kid with a big nose. (Is this a first in the “Peanuts” canon?)
But I suspect that for young audiences, “The Peanuts Movie” will eventually be as much of a launching pad for the work of Charles M. Schulz as previous movie and TV iterations were for their parents.
If “The Peanuts Movie” never quite reaches the melancholy of earlier films like “A Boy Named Charlie Brown” and “Snoopy Come Home,” it nonetheless respects the importance of failure and disappointment that Schulz always included in his storytelling. The football Lucy picks up might be tactile and realistic, but that doesn’t make it any more kickable.
30 Highest Grossing Animated Movies of All Time Worldwide
A look at top animated moneymakers as of May 2020, from "The Lion King" to "Zootopia." The numbers are not adjusted for inflation.
30. "The Incredibles" (2004)
Worldwide Gross: $633,019,734
In 2004, Brad Bird's first Pixar outing wowed audiences with complicated animated action scenes, cross-generational comedy and superhero mayhem.
Pixar Animation Studios
29. "Sing" (2016)
Worldwide Gross: $634,151,679
Illumination's animal-karaoke musical crooned its way onto the list.
28. "Moana" (2016)
Worldwide Gross: $643,331,111
Disney's Hawaii-set movie scored two Oscar nominations, for Best Animated Feature and Lin-Manuel Miranda's song "How Far I'll Go."
Disney
27. "Big Hero 6" (2014)
Worldwide Gross: $657,818,612
Disney's 2014 robot tale combined anime aesthetics, superhero action and Pixar's heart.
Disney Animation Studios
26. "Ice Age: The Meltdown" (2006)
Worldwide Gross: $660,940,780
Fox's 2006 prehistoric romp proved the success of the first was no fluke.
Twentieth Century Fox
25. "Kung Fu Panda 2" (2011)
Worldwide Gross: $665,692,281
With the franchise's skills proven, DreamWorks Animation gave the world another hit of comedy with this animated martial arts sequel in 2011.
Dreamworks Animation Studios
24. "Up" (2009)
Worldwide Gross: $735,099,082
The 2009 fan favorite demonstrated that original ideas with big emotions could make big money.
Pixar Animation Studios
23. "Monsters University" (2013)
Worldwide Gross: $744,229,437
Ten years after the release of "Monsters Inc," Pixar sent fans back to school in a 2013 prequel.
Pixar Animation Studios
22. "Madagascar 3: Europe's Most Wanted" (2012)
Worldwide Gross: $746,921,274
DreamWorks Animation's "Madagascar" series kept the studio afloat with a string of breezy successes, including 2012's third installment.
Dreamworks Animation Studios
21. "Shrek Forever After" (2010)
Worldwide Gross: $752,600,867
The big green ogre's final chapter dropped in 2010.
Dreamworks Animation Studio
20. "Shrek the Third" (2007)
Worldwide Gross: $798,958,162
Made in 2007, this sequel proved there was still some gas left in this fantasy mash-up comedy franchise.
Dreamworks Animation Studio
19. "Coco" (2017)
Worldwide Gross: $807,082,196
Directed by Lee Unkrich, this animated film captured everyone's hearts and even won the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature in 2018.
Disney/Pixar
18. "Inside Out" (2015)
Worldwide Gross: $857,611,174
Disney Pixar hit the home run again with this animated feature film about the emotions inside your head, starring Amy Poehler, Mindy Kaling and Bill Hader.
Disney/Pixar
17. "The Secret Life of Pets" (2016)
Worldwide Gross:$875,457,937
Universal/Illumination's story of dogs seeking out adventure while their owners are away charmed its way onto the list.
Profits abound for this 2012 fourth installment in the chilly prehistoric franchise, followed just behind it's predecessor.
Twentieth Century Fox Animation
15."Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs" (2009)
Worldwide Gross: $888,805,671
While other films have made bigger waves in the States, international sales have always returned big money for Fox's "Ice Age" franchise, proven again by the 2009 entry.
Twentieth Century Fox Animation
14. "Shrek 2" (2004)
Worldwide Gross: $919,838,758
DreamWorks Animation proved to be worthy Pixar competition with its successful "Shrek" franchise.
Dreamworks Animation Studio
13. "Finding Nemo" (2003)
Worldwide Gross: $940,335,536
"Finding Nemo" was something of a second-wind for Pixar, solidifying the company's place as the titans of modern animation.
Pixar Studios
12. "The Lion King" (1994)
Worldwide Gross: $968,483,777
Can you feel the love tonight for this Disney animated classic?
Disney Animation Studios
11. "Despicable Me 2" (2013)
Worldwide Gross: $970,761,885
Illumination's sequel managed to make more money than its predecessor and put the upcoming "Minions" spin-off into motion.
Illumination Studios
10. "Zootopia" (2016)
Worldwide Gross: $1,023,784,195
Disney charmed audiences in 2016 with its cop thriller pairing a rookie rabbit cop and a wily fox informant.
Disney
9. "Finding Dory" (2016)
Worldwide Gross: $1,028,570,889
The sequel to "Finding Nemo" swam right back into audience's hearts.
Pixar
8. "Despicable Me 3" (2017)
Worldwide Gross: $1,034,799,409
Illumination's follow-up -- featuring Gru's blond-haired brother -- became the franchise's biggest grosser.
7. "Toy Story 3" (2010)
Worldwide Gross: $1,066,969,703
Built on Pixar's critical and commercial goodwill, the third installment in the mega-franchise brought in big profits.
Pixar Studios
6. "Toy Story 4" (2019)
Worldwide Gross: $1,073,394,593
Nearly two decades after the last film, Woody and Buzz and the gang returned for the top-grossing film in the series (not adjusted for inflation, that is).
Disney
5. "Minions" (2015)
Worldwide Gross: $1,159,398,397
The little yellow helpers crossed the $1 billion mark at the end of August, raking in more money then "Despicable Me" and "Despicable Me 2" for Universal Pictures.
Universal Pictures/Illumination Entertainment
4. "Incredibles 2" (2018)
Worldwide Gross: $1,242,805,359
The superpowered family sprung back into action a full 14 years after the original -- but far surpassed the original film's box office haul.
Disney/Pixar
3. "Frozen" (2013)
Worldwide Gross: $1,276,480,335
Disney's 2013 smash-hit takes the box office top spot. And then there was merchandising, video on demand and home video that audiences just couldn't let go...
Disney Animation Studios
2. "Frozen II" (2019)
Worldwide Gross: $1,450,026,933
Though it failed to garner an Oscar nom for Best Animated Feature, this sequel still managed to outgross its predecessor.
1. The Lion King (2019)
Worldwide Gross: $1,631,724,000
Whether the film is animated or live-action has been up for debate, the new "Lion King" was computer animated, so we're putting it on the list.
Disney
1 of 31
Cartoon characters that cleaned up at the global box office, from ”The Lion King“ to ”Incredibles 2“
A look at top animated moneymakers as of May 2020, from "The Lion King" to "Zootopia." The numbers are not adjusted for inflation.