A leaked tape in which Donald Trump and his former attorney Michael Cohen discuss a payment to a former Playboy model has set off a high-level debate about whether Trump said the word “don’t” before saying the words “pay with cash.”
The debate resembles the recent viral “Yanny vs. Laurel” argument about what name was pronounced on a particular audio clip. Except this time, the question of what is heard on the tape is relevant to the question of whether the president tried to hide a payoff to conceal an extramarital affair.
The conversation was recorded about two months before the 2016 presidential election, CNN reported. Lanny Davis, a Democrat and attorney for Cohen, told CNN’s Chris Cuomo that Trump is clearly heard on the tape saying “pay with cash.”
Cash payments, unlike payments by check, are hard to track.
Also Read: Mike Cernovich, Who Got James Gunn Fired Over Rape Tweets, Has History of Rape Tweets
“The only people who use cash are drug dealers and mobsters,” Davis said.
But Trump’s legal team pushed back on that narrative, releasing its own transcription of the tape in which they say Trump said: “Don’t pay with cash… check.”
The payment is for a deal involving someone Cohen describes on the tape as “our friend, David.”
The Wall Street Journal reported in November 2016 that the National Enquirer, which is led by Trump friend David Pecker, paid $150,000 to ex-Playboy model Karen McDougal for her account of what she says was an extramarital affair with Trump. The tabloid never ran the story. Critics use the phrase “catch and kill” to refer to the practice of buying stories only to be bury them.
Trump’s campaign spokeswoman, Hope Hicks, told the Journal at the time that the campaign had “no knowledge of any of this.” She also said McDougal’s claim of an affair with Trump was “totally untrue.”
But the tape shows Trump clearly was aware of the payment — whether he asked that it be paid in cash, or that it be paid by check. (You can listen to the audio above and decide for yourself.)
Also Read: Lanny Davis, Ex-Harvey Weinstein Legal Adviser, Now Works for Michael Cohen
Unsurprisingly, Trump supporters said they heard him say, “Don’t pay with cash… check,” while Trump critics said they heard him say only, “Pay with cash.”
“Sounds to me like @realDonaldTrump said ‘Don’t pay with cash,'” Joel Pollack, host of “Breitbart News Tonight,” tweeted. “Cohen says ‘No,’ in agreement, then Trump says, ‘Check.’ This is a giant nothingburger so far, except that @michaelcohen212 and his Clinton lawyer @LannyDavis are declaring war on @POTUS Trump.”
Also Read: 'Morning Joe' Blames Michael Cohen for Trump's Erratic Tweets: 'Driving Him Nuts'
CNN senior congressional correspondent Manu Raju tweeted: “Trump interrupts Cohen asking, ‘What financing?’ according to the recording. When Cohen tells Trump, ‘We’ll have to pay.’ Trump is heard saying ‘pay with cash.'”
Others said the question of cash or check was not the issue.
“Regardless of cash or check, whole point of phony corp. was to hide campaign expenditure,” tweeted Rep. Adam Schiff, top Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee.
Also Read: National Enquirer Publisher Rips Washington Post, Denies Michael Cohen Saw Stories in Advance
See more reactions below.
Trump: I'd like to violate campaign finance laws.
Cohen: Will that be cash or check?
— Joel (@JoelNihlean) July 25, 2018
Trump: “we’ll pay with cash” Cohen “no,no,no” trump “check?”
— Dylan (@gatesofeden36) July 25, 2018
Sounds to me like @realDonaldTrump said "Don't pay with cash." Cohen says "No," in agreement, then Trump says, "Check." This is a giant nothingburger so far, except that @michaelcohen212 and his Clinton lawyer @LannyDavis are declaring war on @POTUS Trump. https://t.co/ZPVVe1wCmZ
— Joel B. Pollak (@joelpollak) July 25, 2018
TRUMP SAID ,'PAY BY CASH, COHEN SAID 'NO, NO, NO, NO, NO! TRUMP IMMEDIATELY SAID CHECK. THAT'S WHAT THE COHEN TAPES SHOWS, SIMPLE AS THAT, & The MEETING WAS IN TRUMPS OFFICE NOT ON PHONE
— TvR (@deevateresa) July 25, 2018
Re the Cohen tape:
1. Cash or check…does it matter? The lack of judgment is the same.
1A. This wasn’t #Trump’s first (payment) rodeo.
2. #Giuliani is an even worse PR guy than he is a lawyer.
— Brian Fitzpatrick (@bdfitzpatrick) July 25, 2018
Re the Cohen tape:
1. Cash or check…does it matter? The lack of judgment is the same.
1A. This wasn’t #Trump’s first (payment) rodeo.
2. #Giuliani is an even worse PR guy than he is a lawyer.
— Brian Fitzpatrick (@bdfitzpatrick) July 25, 2018
Get ready for the new “would” / “wouldn’t” debate: whether Trump said “pay with cash” or “don’t pay with cash” (Rudy said earlier that Trump told Cohen to pay by check) https://t.co/1GhRVWctxY pic.twitter.com/K3i01RhCk8
— Peter Sterne (@petersterne) July 25, 2018
"The only people who use cash are drug dealers and mobsters" Michael Cohen's lawyer, Lanny Davis, tells @ChrisCuomo he released the tape because it contradicts the President's lawyers' claim that Trump told Cohen to write a check – instead of paying cash – to the former model pic.twitter.com/fRdXmPsnuA
— Cuomo Prime Time (@CuomoPrimeTime) July 25, 2018