‘Hercules’ vs. ‘Hercules': 6 Box-Office Battles Between Movies That Were Awfully Alike

'Hercules' vs. 'Hercules': 6 Box-Office Battles Between Movies That Were Awfully Alike

“The Legend of Hercules” is beating “Hercules: The Thracian Wars” to theaters this week, but the first films out don't always win

Last March, the President-in-peril movie “Olympus Has Fallen” opened to a stunning $30 million and wound up taking the steam from the similarly themed (and more expensive) “White House Down,” which flopped in summer.

There will be a similar set-up this week, when Summit Entertainment on Friday rolls out the action-adventure film “The Legend of Hercules,” a $40 million action adventure directed and produced by Renny Harlin and starring Kellan Lutz (“Twilight”).

In July, Paramount and MGM will be releasing “Hercules: The Thracian Wars,” a $110 million sword-and-sandals saga directed by Brett Ratner and starring Dwayne Johnson. That will be six months from now, and it will cut a much wider swath at the box office, most analysts believe.

Also read: Box Office: 2014 Will Likely Be Down, Because Not All Sequels Are Equals

Parallel plot lines aren't at all unusual in the movie biz – insert joke about Hollywood creativity here – as a number of same-theme smack-downs have shown. Here is how a few of the match-ups played out over the years:

DanteVolcano“Dante's Peak” vs. “Volcano,” 1997
This tectonic toss-up was close, but the first film to theaters won out. Universal's bigger-budgeted “Dante's Peak,” starring Pierce Brosnan, opened in February and brought in $67 million domestically and $178 million worldwide. The lava flowed again just two months later, and Universal's “Volcano,” with Tommy Lee Jones as the lead, took in $49 million in the U.S. and made $122 million worldwide.

“Antz” vs. “A Bug's Life,” 1998
This one was a blowout. Pixar's “A Bug's Life,” with Kevin Spacey, Hayden Panettiere and Denis Leary, opened in November and went on to bring in $162 million domestically and more than $360 million globally. DreamWorks Animation's “Antz,” which opened a month earlier and featured bigger names like Woody Allen, Sly Stallone, Sharon Stone and Jennifer Lopez, finished with $90 million domestically and $111 million worldwide.

ArmageddonDeep“Armageddon” vs. “Deep Impact,” 1998
What are the odds of a giant space rock hitting earth? Smaller than two giant space rocks hitting the earth, but that's what moviegoers were looking at this summer.

Paramount and DreamWorks in May rolled out director Mimi Leader's “Deep Impact,” which starred Robert Duvall, Tea Leoni, Elijah Wood and Morgan Freeman and was executive produced by Steven Spielberg. Produced for $80 million, it brought in $140 million in the U.S. and $349 million globally. Michael Bay's “Armageddon,” with Bruce Willis, Ben Affleck, Liv Tyler, Billy Bob Thornton and a $140 million production budget, opened two months later and took in $201 million domestically and $553 million globally.

ChasingLibertyFirstDaughter“Chasing Liberty” vs. “The First Daughter,” 2004
Mandy Moore played the rebellious daughter of the President (Mark Harmon), who finds love in “Chasing Liberty.” Katie Holmes played the daughter of the Chief Executive (Michael Keaton), who finds love in “The First Daughter,” which was directed by Forest Whitaker. Moviegoers elected not to show up, and both of them bombed.

BlartObserve“Paul Blart: Mall Cop” vs. “Observe and Report,” 2010
Kevin James swamped Seth Rogen in this comedic battle of badges. The PG-rated “Paul Blart: Mall Cop” opened in January and was a hit for Sony, taking in $146 million domestically and $183 million worldwide. The R-rated “Observe and Report,” in which Rogen plays a security guard tracking a flasher, was considerably darker. It debuted three months after “Blart” and managed just $26 million domestically.

Friendswithbenefitsnostrings“Friends With Benefits” vs. “No Strings Attached,” 2011
Directed by Ivan Reitman and starring Natalie Portman and Ashton Kutcher, “No Strings Attached” was an R-rated comedy about two friends who get together for casual sex without falling in love. In the R-rated romantic comedy “No Strings Attached,” written and directed by Will Gluck, Justin Timberlake and Mila Kunis naively believe adding sex to their friendship won't mess it up.

Paramount opened “No Strings Attached” in January and it brought in $70 million domestically and $149 million worldwide. Sony rolled out “Friends With Benefits” in July and it brought in $55 million in the U.S. It took in more overseas, however, and wound up with the same $149 million global total.

  • Worst Directors Ever

    Watch the trailer at Apple Trailers…. Summitt's Hercules looks like the biggest
    garbage piece of crap probably wouldn't even be good enough for a Starz

    you thought the emperor has no clothes with the Hemsworth boys, wait
    til you see the acting of Kellan Lutz! He makes them look like De Niro
    to Kellan’s Taylor Lautner.

    But then again, what do you expect from Renny Harlin, one of the worst
    directors of all time, probably up there with Uwe Boll now, who directed
    the biggest bomb of its time, CUTTHROAT ISLAND, as well as films the
    past few years you've never heard of, like DEVIL'S PASS, 5 DAYS OF WAR,
    and the COVENANT, and directed a film on racing, DRIVEN, that's even
    worse than Ron Howard's RUSH this year, if you can “Imagine” that.

    what type of producer says — yes, I want to hire Renny Harlin to
    direct my $70M budgeted film on Hercules, with Brett Ratner is already
    doing one with The Rock?????

    • I'm Your Huckleberry

      You should have started with the showdown between Tombstone and Wyatt Earp.

    • Burphelson AFB

      it's the ole “Hey my d!ck is bigger” syndrome. i.e. the suits at both studios say “I'm making MY movie, eff the other guys.”

  • missed opportunity

    Why isn't White House Down vs. Olympus Has Fallen on here? That was literally a few months ago.

    • Brendan

      Read the beginning of that article, you'll see that they are mentioned on it.

  • Tim Rowland

    Yeah, White House Down lost because the premise sucked! Olympus Has Fallen was a much more plausible storyline, from the bad guys all the way through the plot to the actions of the President (Freeman).

    Johnson's Hercules looks more compelling, and you can't beat the Rock for an action flick calling for a big muscular dude.

    WH Down was nothing but a political attack piece on the military & conservative politics, as well as a puff piece on Obama – He LOVES Lincoln, and is negotiating a Middle-East wide peace treaty. Tell me, how did the producers, writers and directors KNOW that Valerie Jarrett was negotiating with Iran while this movie was being made?? =/