Alfonso Cuaron Says Yes, People Told Him He Was Nuts to Make ‘Roma’
Toronto Film Festival 2018: ”I said to people close to me, ‘I have the opportunity to do this now, but I doubt that this is really going to connect in any way,'“ says Cuaron of his meticulously detailed, black-and-white memory play
“Each object carries its own story,” says Alfonso Cuaron, looking around a room filled with props from his film “Roma.” “Almost, you could do a whole film based on each object.”
The Mexican-born director of “Gravity” and “Children of Men” says this while sitting on a couch in the TIFF Bell Lightbox, headquarters of the Toronto International Film Festival. A fourth-floor gallery in the Lightbox has been turned into a tribute to Cuaron’s exquisite “Roma,” which is based on memories of his childhood growing up in a suburb of Mexico City. And the objects that surround him, from paintings to record albums to children’s games, are things he remembers from childhood and used in the film.
But he went further than simply filling the frame with his own memories, Cuaron tells TheWrap in an interview that takes place while his film is having its triumphant Toronto premiere a block away. Every set on the film, he says, was filled with the things that really would have been there.
“Every single object was going to be in its place,” he says. “We were filling up the drawers with stuff — even those drawers that were never going to be opened or in any scene. They needed to have that energy.”
And did anybody say to him, “Alfonso, you’re nuts – we’re never going to open the drawer”?
“Pretty much there were a lot of comments,” he admits with a grin. “I know those looks, because I come from a more blue-collar background in film, in which you look at directors and say, ‘Oh, my God, this guy doesn’t know how to make a film.'”
He shrugs. “People would say, ‘It doesn’t matter, you’re never going to open the drawer, what’s the difference?’ But there was a big difference. There is something about the process of trying to portray the real — not trying to be realistic, but trying to get to the essence of the real.”
But with a project so consumed with replicating Cuaron’s own childhood memories, was he confident that “Roma” would connect with viewers who have none of his memories?
“Not at all,” he says. “I just knew that I had to do it.
“This was the historical moment that I can do it. I had the resources after the economic success of ‘Gravity’ – I could raise the money to do things this way. But more important, emotionally I was ready and there was a need. You don’t choose projects, they choose you. And once there was this need of doing this film, you go for it.
“Doing it, I said to people close to me, ‘Look, I have the opportunity of doing this now. I’m not going to question it, but I doubt that this is really going to connect in any way.'”
But the Netflix release “Roma,” a black-and-white gem that is also a love letter to the nanny who helped raise Cuaron and his siblings, and who became part of the family, has connected strongly in its festival premieres. In Venice, it won the Golden Lion as the festival’s best film, before heading to Telluride and Toronto and winning additional raves.
“It has been an amazing surprise to see the reaction that people are having to the film,” Cuaron says. “Yes, critics have been fantastic, but you see people from different cultures that come out crying, they feel so connected.
“Even if the story is about about, yes, my own family in the 1970s in a specific setting in a specific country, it’s about families. It just proves that the human experience is one and the same.”
89 Stunning Portraits From TheWrap's Toronto Studio (Exclusive Photos)
Elle Fanning, "Teen Spirit"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Elle Fanning, Clara Rugaard, Zlatko Buric and director Max Minghella, "Teen Spirit"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Elle Fanning, "Teen Spirit"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Alexander Skarsgård, "Hold the Dark"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Mia Goth, Robert Pattinson and director Claire Denis, "High Life"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Maggie Gyllenhaal and Gael Garcia Bernal, "Kindergarten Teacher"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Maggie Gyllenhaal, "Kindergarten Teacher"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Maggie Gyllenhaal, "Kindergarten Teacher"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Maggie Gyllenhaal, "Kindergarten Teacher"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Director Alonso Ruizpalacios and Gael Garcia Bernal, "Museo"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Brian Tyree Henry, Liam Neeson, Colin Farrell and Daniel Kaluuya, "Widows"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Elizabeth Debicki, "Widows"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Colin Farrell, "Widows"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Cynthia Erivo, "Widows"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Kyle MacLachlan and Maria Bello, "Giant Little Ones"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Kyle MacLachlan and Maria Bello, "Giant Little Ones"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Radhika Apte and Dev Patel, "The Wedding Guest"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Radhika Apte and Dev Patel, "The Wedding Guest"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Nicole Kidman, "Destroyer"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Sebastian Stan, Nicole Kidman, Tatiana Maslany and Karyn Kusama, "Destroyer"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Paul Dano, "Wildlife"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Paul Dano and Carey Mulligan, "Wildife"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Jena Malone, "The Public"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Emilio Estevez, Jena Malone, Christian Slater, and Michaek K. Williams, "The Public"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Emilio Estevez, "The Public"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Michael Kenneth Williams, "The Public"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Director Jason Reitman, Matt Bai and Jay Carson, "The Frontrunner"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Adam Stein, Lexy Kolker and Zach Lipovsky, "Freaks"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Garrard Conley and Joel Edgerton, "Boy Erased"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Jason Sudeikis, Judy Greer, Lee Pace, Nick Hamm and Isabel Arraiza, "Driven"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Isabel Arraiza, "Driven"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Lily Rose Depp, "A Faithful Man"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Lily Rose Depp, Louis Garrel and Laetita Casta, "A Faithful Man"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Laetitia Casta, "A Faithful Man"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Laetita Casta and Lily Rose Depp, "A Faithful Man"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Y'Lan Noel, "The Weekend"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Sienna Miller, Jake Scott, Will Sasso, Aaron Paul and Christina Hendricks, "American Woman"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Werner Herzog, "Meeting Gorbachev"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Alexis Bloom, "Divide and Conquer The Story of Roger Ailes"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Taylor Hickson, "Giant Little Ones"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Karyn Kusama, "Destroyer"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
László Nemes, "Sunset"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Lee Chang-dong, "Burning"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Steven Yeun, "Burning"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Darren Mann, Josh Wiggins, and Taylor Hickson, "Giant Little Ones"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Zlatko Buric, "Teen Spirit"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Clara Rugaard, "Teen Spirit"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Max Mingella, "Teen Spirit"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Darren Mann, "Giant Little Ones"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck, "Never Look Away"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Jessie Buckley, "Wild Rose"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Nicole Taylor and Jessie Buckley, "Wild Rose"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Nicole Taylor and Jessie Buckley, "Wild Rose"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Jessie Buckley, "Wild Rose"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Christian Slater, "The Public"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Joel Edgerton, "Boy Erased"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Josh Singer, "First Man"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Josh Wiggins, "Giant Little Ones"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Liam Neeson, "Widows"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Louis Garrel, "A Faithful Man"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Sebastian Koch, "Never Look Away"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Sebastian Stan, "Destroyer"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Tatiana Maslany, "Destroyer"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Thomas Mann, "The Land of Steady Habits"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Thomas Mann, Nicole Holofcener and Ben Mendelsohn, "The Land of Steady Habits"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Tom Schilling, "Never Look Away"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Ali Abbasi, "Border"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Paul Greengrass, Åsne Seierstad, Jonas Strand Gravli, Seda Wit, and Jon Øigarden, "22 July"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Damien Chazelle, Linus Sandgren, Ai-Ling Lee, Tom Cross, and Josh Singer, "First Man"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Errol Morris, "American Dharma"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Judy Greer, "Driven"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Jason Sudeikis, "Driven"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Lee Pace, "Driven"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Jeffrey Wright, "Hold the Dark"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Nadine Labaki, "Capernaum"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Paul Greengrass, "22 July"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Wanuri Kahiu, "Rafiki"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Damien Chazelle, "First Man"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Victor Polster, Lukas Dhont, and Arieh Worthalter, "Girl"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Lukas Dhont, "Girl"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Victor Polster and Arieh Worthalter, "Girl"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Paul Greengrass, Strand Gravli, Jon Oigarden, Seda Wit, and Asne Seierstad, "22 July"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Roddy Doyle and Paddy Breathnach, "Rosie"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Paddy Breathnach, "Rosie"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Roddy Doyle, "Rosie"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Felix Van Groeningen, "Beautiful Boy"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Jason Reitman, "The Front Runner"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
Juli Jakab, "Sunset"
Photographed by Elisabeth Caren for TheWrap
1 of 89
Toronto Film Festival 2018: Maggie Gyllenhaal, Elle Fanning, Robert Pattinson and more stop by our studio