Rachel Maddow Questions Value of Airing Hamas Kidnappings in Israel: ‘They Want It to Be Seen’ (Video)

“I don’t think there is a right decision,” the MSNBC host says

Graphic images and videos have overtaken media coverage of the Israel-Gaza conflict that re-erupted over the weekend with Hamas’ terrorist attack on Israeli civilians, and MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow questioned Monday just how to best navigate them. As the conflict in the Middle East continues, the role of mainstream and social media has become thornier.

“Since the attack on Israel started on Saturday morning, we have seen these murders and hostage takings of civilians and otherwise. We have seen them being filmed and put online for a strategic aim — to advance the purposes of the people who are doing the murdering and the hostage taking,” Maddow said, hosting “The Rachel Maddow Show.”

The journalist shared her dilemma of whether or not to air these clips and images, and expressed that they put “every social media company on Earth” and “everybody in the news business” in a difficult position.

Whereas many families of victims want this footage to be publicly known both for general awareness and in the hopes that more exposure will help them retrieve their loved ones, airing this footage could “potentially” further the work of the Palestinian militant organization.

“They want it to be seen. They want it to augment the terrorizing effect of what they are doing with these innocent people,” Maddow said. “That is a very difficult thing to reckon with. All of these decisions are hard ones. I don’t think there is a right decision.”

Later on Monday’s show, Maddow did show a video of a man and his girlfriend being kidnapped. The host noted that she only aired the clip because the brother of the man who was held hostage specifically asked for her to show it. Maddow also played the video without its sound, in part as to not air the clip’s “propaganda music.”

War always presents a challenge for the media, from how much carnage should be shown to how a conflict should be described. But Israel’s ongoing war with Hamas is proving to be particularly challenging.

For example, X, the company formerly known as Twitter, has noted that the graphic content that’s emerged from the war will remain on the platform due to the “public’s interest.” That being said, the platform also removed “several hundred accounts attempting to manipulate trending topics” and has taken action against “tens of thousands of posts for sharing graphic media, violent speech and hateful conduct.”


2 responses to “Rachel Maddow Questions Value of Airing Hamas Kidnappings in Israel: ‘They Want It to Be Seen’ (Video)”

  1. Golan Avatar

    I understand why Rachel would think this. It’s a humane perspective. The problem is that, especially with all the Jew hatred online (and in real life, sadly), it’s real easy to dismiss these atrocities unless PEOPLE SEE THEM. The thing is… they’re not to be believed. The human mind simply can’t conjure up some of these images because they seem like something from a bad movie… or a fantastical, phantasmagorical tale, spun by a masochist. But not something that could happen in real life. Which makes it easy to call the situation “complicated.” Or engage in both-sides-ism. The world MUST SEE these videos. Videos that weren’t leaked, or stolen. The mass murdering terrorists RELEASED THEM THEMSELVES. Proudly. We need to look evil in the face, without looking away because it’s too much. Only that way will people HAVE to stop denying the truth of the situation. When Black Lives Matter posts that they stand with Palestine mere days after these murders, rapes, beheadings, baby killings, etc., using as their image a silhouette of the paragliding Palestinians that massacred children at a peace & music festival, the world has to SEE how cruel and hateful and barbaric it all is, and how any support for it is tantamount to condoning it. Even Rachel questioning it misses the point. Show it, now and forever. Let the world see who these “people” really are. Who they have always been. And then – after they’ve looked in the mirror and faced their own culpability – let them never again ask Israel for a “cease fire” or to “sit down and negotiate.”

  2. A frightened jew Avatar
    A frightened jew

    Yes.  It must be seen.  Most Everyone hates Jews     I don’t feel safe.  I believe the majority of the world still wants us exterminated.  And we are less than 1% of the world’s population.   I don’t understand the universities and young Americans promoting terrorism and not knowing history. Most Palestinians only want the extermination of Israel- not a two state solution. You can’t negotiate that.  I am scared and broken hearted and literally sick.  

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.